Hushed Hospitals: Why Quiet Is Crucial For Patients

It is considered bad luck to say quiet in a hospital, and many nurses and doctors refuse to utter the word during their shifts. This superstition is so common that it has earned the word quiet the nickname the Q-word. Some people believe that saying quiet during an on-call period will cause a disproportionate increase in workload. However, a randomised trial conducted at Addenbrooke's Hospital in Cambridge refutes this claim.

It's a superstition among nurses

It is considered a superstition among nurses to not say the word "quiet" while at work. This superstition is not unique to nurses, as doctors and other hospital staff also believe in it. The superstition suggests that saying the word "quiet" will cause the hospital to become busy.

This superstition is often referred to as the "quiet effect". It is based on the idea of "regression to the mean", which suggests that when extreme measurements are observed, subsequent measurements will be closer to the average. In the context of the "quiet effect", it is believed that commenting on how quiet the hospital is will result in an increase in patients and, consequently, more work for the staff.

The "quiet effect" is also influenced by cognitive biases, such as confirmation bias, ascertainment bias, and the framing effect. Confirmation bias refers to the tendency to only notice evidence that supports one's belief while rejecting contrary evidence. For example, if someone says "quiet" during their shift, any new patients, even if fewer than average, might be interpreted as a surge because that is what was expected. Ascertainment bias occurs when one's thinking is shaped by their expectations, further reinforcing the belief that saying "quiet" will result in a busier hospital.

While some nurses and hospital staff take this superstition seriously, others find it ridiculous and choose to ignore it. Some believe that it is a coping mechanism for the stressful work environment, allowing staff to feel like they have some control over the unpredictable nature of hospital work.

Despite the lack of scientific evidence supporting the superstition, it remains prevalent among nurses and hospital staff, showcasing the fascinating interplay between human observation, cognitive biases, and the need for rational, scientific thought in healthcare settings.

It's believed to bring about bad luck

It is believed that saying "quiet" in a hospital setting will bring about bad luck. This superstition is especially common among nurses and doctors, despite their profession being grounded in facts and evidence-based thinking.

The superstition is based on the idea that saying "quiet" will cause an influx of patients or emergencies, disrupting the calm. This belief is so widespread that some people working in healthcare settings have developed their own rituals to ward off the perceived bad luck, such as knocking on wood or avoiding the word "quiet" altogether.

The "quiet effect" is a term used to describe this phenomenon. It is often attributed to cognitive biases, such as confirmation bias, ascertainment bias, and the Texas sharpshooter fallacy. Confirmation bias refers to the tendency to only notice evidence that supports one's belief while rejecting contrary evidence. For example, if someone says "quiet" and the next hour is busy, it is blamed on the use of the word, even if the rest of the shift remains calm. Ascertainment bias occurs when expectations shape one's thinking, so that after someone says "quiet," any new patients, even a lower-than-average number, might be interpreted as a surge. The Texas sharpshooter fallacy involves taking shots first and then painting the target where the shots land, essentially claiming correlation where there is none.

While many people working in healthcare are aware that saying "quiet" does not actually cause an increase in patients, the superstition remains pervasive, and some even report being chewed out or reamed out by colleagues for uttering the word.

Despite the lack of scientific evidence supporting the superstition, some healthcare professionals continue to avoid saying "quiet," knocking on wood, or using alternative phrases like "cruisey" to describe a calm period in the hospital.

It's referred to as the Q-word

In hospitals, it is considered bad luck to say the word "quiet" out loud. This superstition is referred to as the "Q-word" or the "quiet effect". Many doctors and nurses believe that uttering this word will result in an influx of patients or emergencies, disrupting the calm atmosphere.

The "quiet effect" is a phenomenon that has been observed and discussed by medical professionals. Some believe that saying "quiet" will jinx the department, bringing chaos and busyness. This belief is often met with scepticism, with some medical professionals attributing it to cognitive biases such as confirmation bias and ascertainment bias.

The superstition holds that mentioning the word "quiet" will lead to an immediate increase in workload, as if the words spoken have the power to influence reality. This belief is so strong that some hospital staff members will even knock on wood or take other actions to ward off the perceived bad luck that follows saying the Q-word.

While some medical professionals acknowledge the "quiet effect" as a harmless superstition, others find it irritating or bothersome. Some doctors and nurses may even reprimand their colleagues for uttering the Q-word, perpetuating the belief that saying "quiet" will bring about negative consequences.

Despite the strong beliefs surrounding the "quiet effect", there is no scientific evidence to support a causal link between saying "quiet" and an increase in hospital admissions or emergencies. In fact, some studies have been conducted to specifically address this superstition, with results indicating that saying "quiet" has no impact on patient volume or workload.

It's thought to increase the clinician's workload

The superstition that saying "quiet" in a hospital will increase the clinicians' workload is a widely held belief among medical professionals. While some find it bothersome or silly, others take it seriously, knocking on wood or avoiding the word "quiet" altogether. This superstition is not limited to hospitals; it also applies to pathology clinics and veterinary medicine.

The "quiet effect" is a term used to describe the phenomenon where saying "quiet" in a hospital is followed by an increase in patient volume or workload. However, this is simply a correlation, and there is no causal relationship between the word "quiet" and an increase in workload. The use of the word "quiet" in the emergency department is not associated with patient volume, as confirmed by a randomized controlled trial published in PubMed.

The belief in the "quiet effect" can be attributed to cognitive biases, specifically confirmation bias. People tend to remember the times when they said "quiet" and something happened but overlook the times when nothing occurred. This bias reinforces the idea that saying "quiet" is followed by chaos. Additionally, ascertainment bias plays a role, as expecting an increase in patients after saying "quiet" can shape one's perception and interpretation of new patients as a surge.

While some medical professionals find the "quiet" superstition bothersome or silly, others have embraced it as a harmless way to cope with the stress of working in a hospital setting. They may knock on wood, avoid saying "quiet", or even refer to it as the "Q-word." However, it's important to note that this superstition is just that—a belief that is not based on scientific evidence.

In conclusion, the idea that saying "quiet" in a hospital will increase the clinicians' workload is a widely held superstition among medical professionals. While some find it annoying or ridiculous, others take it seriously, adhering to various rituals to avoid tempting fate. However, there is no scientific evidence to support a causal link between saying "quiet" and an increase in workload. The correlation observed in the "quiet effect" can be explained by cognitive biases, specifically confirmation bias and ascertainment bias.

It's considered a joke by some

The idea that you should never say "quiet" in a hospital is considered a joke by some, who view it as a silly superstition. This superstition is not unique to hospitals, with some believing in a similar concept called "call karma", where certain doctors attract sicker patients while on call.

Some people who work in hospitals believe that saying the word "quiet" will cause the department to become busy. One person who works in the emergency department shared their experience of saying "it's strangely quiet tonight", which was followed by shocked expressions from their colleagues. Within minutes, paramedics called in with a VSA (Vital Signs Absent), and there was a multiple motor vehicle collision followed by a man having a stroke. Another person shared that they were working a 12-hour shift when a patient said, "Boy, it's quiet around here today". The patient was told, "You said the Q word!", and a minute later, the fire alarm went off and the hospital called a Code Red.

Some people who do not believe in the superstition have pointed out that the "quiet effect" can be explained by regression to the mean, where extreme measurements are followed by measurements closer to the true average. Additionally, cognitive biases such as confirmation bias, ascertainment bias, the framing effect, feedback sanction, and the fundamental attribution error may contribute to the perception that saying "quiet" causes an increase in workload.

While some people find the superstition irritating or ridiculous, others do not get mad but may knock on wood or take other actions to ward off bad luck. Some people who do not believe in the superstition have embraced it as a fun tradition, knocking on the table three times instead of saying "quiet".

Frequently asked questions