State Hospital Commitment: Who Decides?

Involuntary commitment, also known as civil commitment, is the legal process of placing someone in an inpatient setting such as a hospital psychiatric unit or a mental hospital against their will. The criteria for civil commitments vary but often include presenting an imminent danger to oneself or others due to a mental disorder. The process for commitment varies from state to state, and each state has procedures in place to prevent unjustified detention, such as requirements for medical certification or judicial approval. While commitment may be seen as a way to get someone mental health help when they refuse, it can also cause unnecessary trauma and fear. During hospitalization, patients undergo various assessments, including physical and psychiatric evaluations, and are provided with treatment plans focused on preparing them to return to the community.

Involuntary commitment laws vary by state

Involuntary commitment laws exist in every state in the US, outlining the process for connecting someone in crisis to treatment. However, the specifics of these laws vary by state, with each state having its own statutes and regulations. These laws aim to balance personal rights with protecting public safety and providing care for those unable or unwilling to seek it.

The criteria for involuntary commitment vary but often include presenting an imminent danger to oneself or others, with states interpreting "dangerousness" differently. For example, Colorado allows for involuntary commitment for drug or alcohol use disorder for up to 180 days, while Arizona does not include substance use disorder as a viable cause. On the other hand, Vermont allows involuntary commitment for substance use disorder, and Rhode Island permits it for alcoholism.

The process for involuntary commitment typically begins with a petition or evaluation by a mental health professional, who can commit a patient for a short-term emergency detention, usually 72 hours, if they are a danger to themselves or others. This can be initiated by concerned family members or healthcare providers, and most states require medical evaluation or court approval. The allowed duration of emergency detentions varies, with some states allowing for longer periods of up to 10 days. Following this, civil commitment proceedings must be initiated, which can result in additional commitments of 14, 90, or 180 days.

It is important to note that involuntary commitment is not meant to be punitive but rather a way to help individuals in crisis by connecting them to appropriate treatment. While commitment standards exist in all states, very few states make use of involuntary outpatient commitment laws, and inpatient commitment is more commonly used.

Civil commitment standards

Civil commitment, also known as involuntary commitment or hospitalization, is a legal process that allows a qualified person to detain an individual with severe mental health issues in a psychiatric hospital for treatment. This treatment may include the involuntary administration of psychoactive drugs. The criteria for civil commitment vary between nations and even states, but often include presenting an imminent danger to oneself or others.

In the United States, civil commitment standards have evolved from being based on a right to treatment for patients with mental illness to being based on dangerousness. The decision to involuntarily hospitalize an individual is a difficult one, and psychiatrists are guided by state laws defining the standards for involuntary treatment. These laws serve as guidelines for physicians dealing with patients who refuse hospital admission. While civil commitment standards vary across states, some general procedures are in place to prevent individuals from being unjustly detained, such as requirements for medical certification or judicial approval.

In Washington, civil commitment is one of two routes for admission to a state psychiatric hospital. It begins with an evaluation by a county-designated mental health professional, who can commit a patient for a 72-hour evaluation if they are deemed dangerous to themselves or others due to a mental disorder. Subsequent court hearings can result in additional commitments of 14, 90, or 180 days. While at the state hospitals, civilly committed patients live on locked wards but can earn off-ward privileges based on their treatment progress.

In Texas, patients admitted to state hospitals undergo a comprehensive admission process, including a psychiatric evaluation, physical examination, and various diagnostic tests. All incoming patients and their belongings are searched to ensure the safety of the patient and others. Texas state hospitals have a strict no-tobacco policy, banning all tobacco and nicotine products on hospital property.

It's important to note that civil commitment is intended to help individuals and is not meant to be punitive or restrictive of their rights. Patients can sue if they believe they have been wrongfully committed, and social workers assist in finding appropriate placements for their transition out of the hospital.

Patient admission procedures

In general, to be involuntarily admitted to a psychiatric hospital, an individual must show symptoms of mental illness and pose a danger to themselves or others. However, some states do not require that a person meets both criteria and may still consider involuntary hospitalization if the individual is refusing needed treatment for mental illness.

In the case of emergency hospitalization, the court will appoint a guardian to represent the patient during detention. Additionally, patients who are unable to agree to hospitalization due to their medical condition (e.g., unconsciousness or a stroke) will have their admission reported to the court by the healthcare provider.

Upon admission, the patient's information is entered into the hospital's database and computer system, including identification data, date of admission, diagnosis, and medical record number. The patient is then greeted and made to feel comfortable and relaxed. Their identity is verified, and their medical condition is evaluated. They are introduced to their roommates, staff, surroundings, and daily routine, and any necessary supplies and equipment are provided.

For patients requiring long-term care and repeated hospitalization, nursing activities must be coordinated to ensure continuous nursing care. The specific medical treatment prescribed by the doctor and the nursing regime followed by the nurse are administered by the nurse according to the patient's needs.

Patient privileges

Patients in state hospitals are guaranteed certain rights under state and federal laws. These rights vary depending on the state and the type of patient, but there are some commonalities. For example, all patients have the right to privacy, dignity, respect, and humane care, as well as the right to be free from harm, abuse, or neglect.

In California, patients in maximum-security facilities are allowed in general patient access areas within the secured perimeters of the hospital but not outside of it. They have the right to physical exercise and recreational opportunities, to wear their own clothes, and to keep and use their own personal possessions, including toiletry articles. They are also allowed to have an unlimited amount of funds in their hospital account for canteen purchases and miscellaneous expenses, and to have access to individual storage space for their private use. They are permitted to see visitors each day and have reasonable access to telephones to make and receive confidential calls.

In New York, patients have the right to receive a discharge notice 24 hours before leaving the hospital, and to receive a written discharge plan before they leave. This plan should outline any health care services the patient may need after discharge, and it is the responsibility of the hospital to ensure that these services are secured or reasonably available. Patients in New York also have the right to request a DNR (do-not-resuscitate) order, which instructs medical staff not to try to revive the patient if their breathing or heartbeat has stopped. This request can be made verbally or in writing, as long as there are two witnesses present.

In terms of clinical privileges, these refer to the permissions granted to healthcare providers to provide clinical care in a hospital. They outline what procedures a provider is allowed to perform and are determined by state law and the delineation of privileges listed by the hospital. For example, a midwife would typically have the privilege to attend births but not to perform a cardiac catheterization.

Discharge planning

In the United States, discharge planning is required for hospital accreditation. The process is individualized for each patient, taking into account their specific needs and circumstances. It involves providing patients with instructions and information to ensure a smooth transition and promote healing and recovery outside the hospital setting.

Key components of discharge planning include assessing the patient's physical and psychological ability to follow discharge instructions, perform activities of daily living, and understand their diagnosis, medications, and any necessary lifestyle modifications. Additionally, discharge planning entails evaluating the patient's home situation, caregiver support, and access to necessary follow-up care. This includes identifying benefit eligibility, such as Veterans Affairs, Social Security, Medi-Cal, or other benefits, to ensure continuity of care.

Social workers play a vital role in discharge planning, particularly for patients admitted to state hospitals. They gather information and focus on critical aspects of community living, including housing, finances, and aftercare needs. With patient consent, social workers collaborate with identified primary family contacts to discuss resources and needs related to the discharge. The goal is to discharge patients back into their communities, empowering them to participate meaningfully in their chosen environments.

Effective discharge planning also involves coordination between multidisciplinary teams, including professionals from healthcare, social care, housing, and the voluntary and community sectors. This collaborative approach ensures that the patient's needs are comprehensively addressed and that all legal responsibilities and requirements, such as those outlined in the Mental Health Act 1983, are met.

Frequently asked questions