Understanding Hospital Doctor Payment Structures

Understanding how doctors are paid in hospitals is a complex process with many variables. In the United States, doctors are paid more than in other countries, with some experts arguing that this is due to the limited supply of doctors. Doctors can be paid by hospitals, insurance companies, or separate medical groups, and their salaries can be influenced by factors such as specialty, time worked, and productivity. Independent doctors tend to earn more but often work longer hours, while salaried doctors may enjoy a better work-life balance. Compensation structures are evolving, with hospitals considering changes to address Medicare rules and regulations.

Doctors are paid a salary, or hourly rate, depending on their employer

Doctors' salaries are determined by a variety of factors, including their employer, specialty, and productivity. While some doctors are paid a salary, others may be paid an hourly rate or through alternative methods such as bonuses or practice financial performance. The way doctors are paid varies depending on their employer and the specific arrangements they have made.

Many doctors who work in hospitals are directly employed by the hospital and receive a salary from the hospital. This is especially common for doctors who are tired of running their own practices and prefer to focus solely on practising medicine. In these cases, the hospital typically guarantees the doctor a set salary, which can be quite lucrative.

On the other hand, many doctors who work in hospitals are not actually employed by the hospital but rather by a separate medical group that has a contract to staff the hospital. In these cases, the doctor's salary is paid by the medical group, not the hospital. This can create a complicated payment structure, as the doctor may be seeing patients and providing services on behalf of the hospital, but their compensation is still determined by the medical group.

Some doctors who own their practices may receive a combination of salary and productivity-based compensation. Their salary may be based on factors such as specialty, time worked, and prior year's productivity. However, doctors who own their practices often have to work longer hours to see enough patients to make their practices profitable, which can be challenging for those with families or other commitments.

In the United States, doctors are paid more than in other similar economies, and working in the US is the best way to ensure the highest potential salary for a doctor. However, the supply of doctors in the US is limited by medical associations, which control the number of medical school slots and residencies. This complex interplay of factors influences the salaries and compensation packages offered to doctors by hospitals and other employers.

Doctors who own their practices are paid differently to employees

There are several differences in the payment structures of doctors who own their practices and those who are employees. Firstly, salary accounts for a larger proportion of compensation for physicians who are employees, whereas doctors who own their practices derive a larger portion of their income from productivity and practice financial performance. In 2016, salary accounted for 69.9% of compensation for employed physicians, compared to 30.1% for practice owners. Similarly, productivity accounted for 22.3% of compensation for employed physicians and 44.7% for practice owners.

The shift from practice ownership to employment has been influenced by a generational change, with younger doctors opting for employment to avoid further debt and to pursue diverse career interests. In 2018, for the first time, employed physicians outnumbered practice owners, marking a significant change in the industry.

Financial risk is another key differentiator between the two groups. Doctors who own their practices assume greater financial risk, including capital investment, debt guarantees, and day-to-day operating costs. They may also face higher tax obligations and need to navigate the complexities of business management alongside their medical practice. On the other hand, employed physicians benefit from structured work-life balance, job security, and reduced administrative duties.

Specialty, time worked in the practice, and prior year's productivity are significant factors in determining the salary for both groups. However, ownership status and practice type influence the weight of these factors, with patient satisfaction scores also playing a role in some cases.

While employed physicians may receive a straight salary or a salary with production bonuses, practice owners encounter various compensation formulas. These may include equal splits, production-based pay, or a hybrid model. Stipends for administrative duties are also common for practice owners. Ultimately, the choice between employment and practice ownership depends on individual circumstances, career goals, and personal preferences.

Doctors' pay is determined by their specialty, time worked, and productivity

Doctors' pay is influenced by a variety of factors, and there is no one-size-fits-all model for compensation. The pay structure for doctors can be influenced by their specialty, the time worked, productivity, and the practice setting.

Specialty is a significant factor in determining a doctor's salary. According to surveys, 61.1% of physicians receiving a salary cited specialty as the most frequent salary determinant. This is especially true for doctors who own their practices or are in solo practice, as their compensation is directly linked to their specialty and practice performance. For example, a cardiologist or an orthopedic surgeon may earn more due to their specialized skills.

Time worked is another critical factor in doctors' pay. About 45.2% of physicians stated that the time worked in their practice influenced their salary. Doctors who own their practices may need to work longer hours to see enough patients and make their practices profitable. This can result in longer work hours to balance the demands of running a practice and providing patient care.

Productivity also plays a significant role in determining doctors' pay. In some cases, physicians are compensated based on their productivity, with higher productivity leading to higher earnings. This can be measured through various models, such as the wRVU productivity model, which takes into account the complexity and severity of cases. Additionally, prior-year productivity was cited by 32.2% of physicians as a factor influencing their current salary.

It is important to note that doctors' pay structures can vary depending on their employment status and practice setting. For example, doctors who are employed by hospitals or groups may receive a fixed salary, while independent doctors or practice owners may have their pay more closely tied to productivity and practice financial performance. Additionally, factors such as patient satisfaction scores and clinical report cards can also influence compensation, although to a lesser extent.

Furthermore, it is worth mentioning that doctors in the United States tend to earn higher salaries compared to their counterparts in other countries. This is partly due to the limited supply of doctors and the higher rates of reimbursement from insurance companies and Medicare.

Doctors are paid by insurance companies, or the patient directly

The payment structure for doctors can be complicated and varies depending on the doctor and the setting. Doctors can be paid in several ways, including through salary, hourly rates, or per patient. Many doctors who work in hospitals are employed by separate medical groups that have contracts with the hospital. In these cases, doctors are typically paid a salary with benefits by the medical group rather than the hospital directly. Performance metrics, such as the number of patients seen per hour, may also influence their compensation.

Some doctors own their practices and receive compensation based on personal productivity and practice financial performance. In these cases, doctors may have more control over their income, but they often need to work longer hours to see enough patients to make their practices profitable. This can be a challenging arrangement for doctors with families or other commitments outside of work.

Doctors' salaries can also be influenced by factors such as specialty, time worked in the practice, and prior year's productivity. Additionally, doctors may receive bonuses, commissions, or compensation from pharmaceutical or medical device companies for promotional talks, research, and consulting. However, it is prohibited by law for doctors to receive bonuses or commissions from drug companies.

In terms of insurance companies' involvement, patients with coinsurance plans may impact how doctors are paid. If a patient exceeds their out-of-pocket maximum, the insurance company may need to pay the coinsurance amount to the doctor, which is a fixed percentage of the total cost. Additionally, when a patient has a copayment (a fixed dollar amount per visit), the hospital typically collects this payment. However, if the doctor's practice bills separately, they may not be entitled to an additional copayment from the insurance company.

Overall, the trend in physician compensation is moving towards alternative payment methods, but personal productivity remains a key factor in determining doctors' pay, especially for those who own their practices.

Doctors may receive additional income from pharmaceutical companies

Doctors may receive additional income from pharmaceutical and medical device companies in the form of promotional talks, research, consulting, and royalties from inventions. This practice has raised concerns about the potential influence of commercial interests on medical practice. While smaller payments are more common, even these smaller amounts may impact a physician's behaviour and prescribing habits.

In the United States, the federal Open Payments initiative, part of the 2010 Affordable Care Act, requires companies to publicly disclose payments made to physicians. This information can be accessed by patients through databases such as Dollars for Docs and the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services Open Payments site. Despite scrutiny, high earnings from these additional sources of income have become commonplace, with over 2,500 physicians receiving at least $500,000 each from drug and medical device companies in a five-year period.

Some physicians defend these payments, arguing that they are legitimate and do not necessarily indicate negative consequences. However, researchers have found that top-promoted drugs may be less effective, safe, and affordable than top-selling or most-prescribed drugs. This suggests that promotional campaigns and financial incentives from pharmaceutical companies should be viewed with caution.

The impact of these additional income streams on physician behaviour and prescribing practices is an ongoing area of study and scrutiny. While it is important to recognise the potential benefits of industry-physician collaborations, ensuring patient care is not compromised and commercial interests do not influence medical practice is crucial.

Frequently asked questions