German Hospitals: Migrant Crisis Management

In 2015, Germany recorded the highest rates of refugees since the early 1990s, with an estimated 1.3 million migrants entering the country. This surge in migration has posed significant challenges for German hospitals and the healthcare system as a whole. While Germany has implemented various measures to provide medical care for migrants, including outpatient clinics and services, concerns have been raised about inequalities in healthcare access and the potential strain on resources. Language barriers, cultural differences, and legal regulations further complicate the situation, leading to reports of German hospitals being pushed to their breaking point.

Migrants face barriers in accessing specialised treatment for trauma and torture

In Germany, migrants face several barriers in accessing specialised treatment for trauma and torture. Firstly, there is a critical strain on multilingual healthcare professionals, who are often migrants themselves. The influx of requests can overwhelm these practitioners, leading to long waiting times for patients. Additionally, there is a limited number of specialised centres for refugees and victims of torture, such as the Psychosocial Support Centres for Refugees and Victims of Torture (BAFF), and they may be located far from the patient's residence. These centres rely heavily on donations and external funds as therapies are typically not covered by health and social authorities for asylum seekers.

The lack of specialised centres results in asylum seekers being directed to general psychological care facilities, where they may encounter language or cultural barriers. Interpreters or psychologists without specific training in assisting refugees and victims of torture can lead to misunderstandings and inappropriate treatment. Furthermore, asylum seekers often struggle to meet the legal requirements for proof of medical conditions in asylum procedures, as they need a qualified certificate from a medical specialist. This challenge is exacerbated in regions like Bavaria, where access to general practitioners is extremely difficult for asylum seekers residing in AnKER Dependancen.

Undocumented migrants, or those without a legal right to remain in Germany, face additional obstacles in accessing healthcare. They are generally not entitled to free medical care as they are not insured. While hospitals are legally obliged to treat emergencies, there is a risk that they will refuse to admit patients without documents. Even when treatment is provided, it may be substandard due to hospitals not receiving reimbursement for treating uninsured patients. To overcome these challenges, undocumented migrants may seek help through their personal networks or turn to non-governmental organisations like Medinetz (Medibüro) and charities such as the Malteser Catholic charity.

Migrants and refugees seeking mental health support face complex and specialised challenges. They may experience stigma associated with mental health issues within their communities and the host country, deterring them from seeking help. Navigating a new society and healthcare system can also be stressful and traumatic, adding to their existing burdens. To address these challenges, initiatives like the pilot project launched by MSF in 2017 aimed to train refugees as psychosocial peer counselors. These programs enable newcomers to connect with other refugees, learn coping techniques, and break down cultural and language barriers while improving access to mental health services.

Hospitals are legally obliged to treat undocumented migrants in emergencies

In Germany, undocumented migrants are not generally entitled to free medical care as they are not insured. However, hospitals are legally obliged to treat anyone who comes to them in an emergency, regardless of their documentation status or ability to pay. This means that undocumented migrants have limited access to medical care, and often have to rely on their own networks or non-governmental organisations for help.

In Germany, there is no legal obligation for healthcare providers to inquire about or report a patient's immigration status to federal immigration authorities. Hospital staff, whether medical or administrative, do not have the right to report people with no legal residency to the police or immigration authorities. However, there is a risk that hospitals may refuse to admit patients without documents, despite the legal requirement to treat them. Hospitals do not receive any reimbursement for treating uninsured patients, which has led to refusals and sub-standard treatment in the past.

To address the issue of limited access to healthcare for undocumented migrants, several organisations and initiatives have been established in Germany. Medinetz (also known as Medibüro) is a network of non-governmental organisations that offer anonymous help to those without legal papers who need to see a doctor. They provide referrals to doctors and operate in several cities across Germany. Similarly, the Malteser Catholic charity has 20 clinics throughout Germany, providing medical and dental care to people without residency permits.

In 2015, Germany experienced the highest rates of refugees since the early 1990s, which led to the establishment of special outpatient services in several German cities. In Cologne, for example, an outpatient clinic (OPD) was set up in the largest emergency accommodation centre for refugees, supported by the municipality and operated by the German Red Cross and physicians from the Association of Statutory Health Insurance Physicians. This clinic provided low-threshold access to medical care and integration into the German regulatory healthcare system for refugees.

Language barriers and legal regulations hinder access to healthcare for migrants

Germany has seen a growing number of people with migrant backgrounds, with over 20% of its population of about 82.4 million people having a migrant background. This has brought to light the difficulties migrants face in accessing healthcare. Language barriers and legal regulations are two major hurdles that hinder access to healthcare for migrants in Germany.

Firstly, language barriers pose a significant challenge for migrants seeking healthcare in Germany. Many migrants do not speak German, which makes it difficult for them to communicate their health concerns and understand medical instructions. This can lead to misunderstandings and potentially affect the quality of care they receive. In addition, the lack of a regular translation service during consultation hours further exacerbates the issue. While web-based translation programs, multilingual staff members, or peers with basic knowledge of German may assist, this is not always sufficient or accurate.

Secondly, legal regulations and the asylum system also hinder access to healthcare for migrants. Undocumented migrants, or those without a legal right to remain in Germany, are generally not entitled to free medical care as they are not insured. While hospitals are legally obliged to treat emergencies, there is still a risk that they may refuse to admit patients without documents. Additionally, the Asylum-Seekers' Benefits Act restricts social services for asylum seekers, focusing primarily on "acute diseases and pain." Treatment for chronic diseases requires approval, which can lead to delays in treatment and potentially life-threatening consequences.

Furthermore, psychological support for refugees and victims of torture is limited, with only 47 Psychosocial Support Centres in Germany, long waiting lists, and a lack of proximity to the centres. Necessary but expensive diagnostic measures or therapies are also not always granted by local authorities, further restricting access to healthcare for migrants.

To address these issues, Germany has established special outpatient services in several cities, such as Cologne, to simplify access to the regular healthcare system. NGOs like Medinetz (Medibüro) and charities like the Malteser Catholic Charity also provide medical assistance to undocumented migrants. However, these initiatives may not be enough to overcome the barriers, and further efforts are needed to ensure equitable access to healthcare for migrants in Germany.

Migrants with mental health issues face unmet needs in the healthcare system

Migrants and refugees face complex and specialized health challenges, especially in the area of mental health. Mental health issues among migrants and refugees are often caused by traumatic events (TEs) experienced prior to and during their flight. These events involve unmet basic needs for survival, such as regular access to water, food, and shelter; fearing for one's life; witnessing acts of violence; living in a war zone; and forced separation from family. Exposure to TEs is a major risk factor for the development of mental disorders such as post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), depression, and anxiety disorders.

In Germany, migrants and refugees face barriers in accessing mental health services. These barriers include language discordance, cultural differences, and restricted access to mainstream healthcare. For example, undocumented migrants in Germany are not generally entitled to free medical care and may face challenges in obtaining the necessary treatment. While hospitals are legally obligated to treat emergencies, there have been reports of hospitals refusing to admit undocumented patients or providing sub-standard care.

To address these challenges, Germany has established special outpatient services for refugees in several cities, supported by organizations like the German Red Cross. Additionally, networks of non-governmental organizations, such as Medinetz (Medibüro), provide referrals and support for migrants without legal papers to access medical care. However, these services may not fully meet the complex mental health needs of migrants and refugees, who often require integrated and specialized care.

The situation has led to concerns about the well-being of both migrant patients and their caregivers. Migrants living in shared asylum accommodations have reported increased psychological distress, and a Greek study found that caregivers working with refugees experienced psychological stresses, sleep disturbances, and PTSD. These issues highlight the urgent need for tailored health policies and management practices to address the mental health challenges faced by migrants and refugees in Germany.

Charities and NGOs provide free medical care to undocumented migrants

In Germany, undocumented migrants are not generally entitled to free medical care as they are not insured. However, they can access emergency care in hospitals, as hospitals are legally obliged to treat emergencies and are not permitted to report people with no legal residency to the authorities. Nevertheless, hospitals may refuse to admit patients without documents.

Several charities and NGOs provide free medical care to undocumented migrants in Germany. For example, the Catholic charity, the Malteser, has 20 clinics providing medical and dental care for people without residency permits. Medinetz (also known as Medibüro or Medibuero) is a network of NGOs that helps those without legal papers to see a doctor. They provide referrals to see a doctor, and their services are anonymous. Praxis ohne Grenzen (clinics without borders) has clinics in Northern Germany and in Solingen, and open.med offers medical treatment and advice for migrants in difficult living situations or without insurance in Berlin, Hamburg, Munich, and Stuttgart.

In Berlin, state public health services only offer prenatal care and treatment for tuberculosis and some sexually transmitted infections. All other medical care for uninsured migrants is provided by NGOs offering free clinics or anonymous consultations with general practitioners and specialists. These NGOs are primarily funded by donations.

Outpatient services for refugees have been established in several German cities, such as in Cologne, where an outpatient clinic was set up in the largest emergency accommodation centre for refugees with support from the municipality and operated by the German Red Cross and physicians from the Association of Statutory Health Insurance Physicians.

Frequently asked questions