Disease Outbreaks: Financial Impact On Hospitals

Disease outbreaks can have a significant impact on hospitals' financial stability, and the COVID-19 pandemic has provided a clear example of this. During outbreaks, hospitals' focus shifts to crisis management, often suspending preventive and elective procedures, which results in decreased revenue. Additionally, outbreaks can lead to staffing shortages as healthcare workers fall sick or have to quarantine, and hospitals may need to offer higher pay to attract staff. Other financial burdens include the cost of supplies and equipment, and potential import tariff increases. These factors can negatively affect hospitals' financial performance and sustainability, particularly for non-profit teaching hospitals.

Hospitals lose revenue due to patients avoiding non-essential care

During the COVID-19 pandemic, patients avoided receiving preventive or elective healthcare services due to concerns about disease transmission and local ordinances. This resulted in a loss of revenue for hospitals, as these services tend to be higher-paying and elective in nature. The pandemic also caused disruptions to hospital operations, with anecdotal evidence suggesting that financial performance suffered.

The avoidance of non-essential care by patients during the pandemic led to a decrease in revenue for many healthcare delivery organizations. This was further compounded by challenges in lending conditions and competition from large multi-hospital systems that do not support graduate medical education. The financial outlook for teaching hospitals, which generally operate as non-profit and public entities, was downgraded from stable to negative in March 2020.

Hospitals also faced increased costs due to the pandemic. Labor expenses dominated hospital costs, accounting for 56% of total costs, and Medicare and Medicaid underpaid hospitals by an estimated $130 billion in 2023. Tariff-related import expenses were also expected to raise hospital costs, and hospitals anticipated buying less equipment or delaying upgrades to manage their financial situation.

The COVID-19 pandemic also impacted the standard of care provided by hospitals. With limited resources, such as hospital space, beds, staffing, and supplies, healthcare systems had to adapt to a crisis standard of care. This shift in focus led to the suspension of preventive and elective procedures, which could result in liability for medical malpractice if delays in treatment or diagnosis caused harm.

Overall, the COVID-19 pandemic negatively affected the financial performance of hospitals, with revenue losses due to patients avoiding non-essential care being a significant contributing factor.

Staff shortages are exacerbated by disease outbreaks

Staff shortages are a significant challenge for hospitals during disease outbreaks, with healthcare workers falling sick or having to quarantine after exposure. This issue was prominent during the COVID-19 pandemic, where hospitals faced financial strain and staffing shortages. The pandemic disrupted hospital operations, and financial performance suffered due to reduced elective procedures and preventive care.

The impact of staffing shortages on hospitals during disease outbreaks is multi-faceted. Firstly, the available staff may become overworked, leading to increased stress and exhaustion, which can result in human errors and negatively impact patient safety. Overworked staff may also struggle to keep up with infection prevention methods, increasing the risk of transmission to other patients and staff. This was particularly evident during the COVID-19 outbreak, where the focus on infection control was critical.

Secondly, hospitals may have to offer higher salaries and sign-on bonuses to attract staff, especially in high-demand roles like nursing. This can lead to a "brain drain" in hospitals that cannot afford these incentives, further exacerbating staffing inequalities. Additionally, the undervaluing and under-compensation of infectious disease specialists have led to declining interest in this field, impacting hospitals' ability to adequately respond to outbreaks.

The financial strain caused by staffing shortages during outbreaks can also impact hospitals' ability to invest in new equipment and upgrades, further affecting their ability to provide quality care. This creates a cycle where hospitals struggle to recover financially, and staff continue to be overworked and under-resourced, potentially leading to a decline in overall healthcare system performance.

To mitigate these challenges, hospitals can partner with community organizations to create inclusive philanthropic initiatives, raise awareness, and provide education and resources. These collaborative efforts can help promote equitable solutions and ensure hospitals are better prepared to handle the financial and staffing burdens associated with disease outbreaks.

Changes to malpractice laws during outbreaks can negatively impact patients

During a disease outbreak, hospitals may experience a decrease in revenue due to patients avoiding non-essential healthcare services. This, coupled with the increased costs associated with outbreak management, can put hospitals in a financially challenging position.

In the case of the COVID-19 pandemic, hospitals had to deal with changes to malpractice laws and regulations at the state and federal levels. While the specifics of these changes are unclear, it is mentioned that such radical changes rarely benefit the average person.

Changes to malpractice laws during outbreaks may negatively impact patients

During a disease outbreak, the standard of care changes as healthcare systems adapt to resource limitations. The focus shifts from individual patients to addressing the immediate needs of larger groups. As hospitals deviate from conventional standards of care, many preventive and elective procedures are suspended, which can lead to the progression of serious conditions that could have been treated earlier.

For example, during the COVID-19 outbreak, there was an increased risk of diagnostic errors, as overwhelmed health systems with staffing shortages struggled to keep up. This could have resulted in missed or delayed diagnoses of non-COVID-19 conditions due to the presumption that patients had contracted coronavirus.

In such situations, patients may find it more difficult to pursue medical malpractice lawsuits successfully. While the number of medical malpractice lawsuits filed each year is relatively low, and they account for a tiny percentage of personal injury litigation, the laws and regulations surrounding malpractice are complex and vary between states. To win monetary compensation, patients need to prove that substandard medical care resulted in injury or harm, which can be challenging when the standard of care has shifted due to the outbreak.

Furthermore, the emotional stress and physical exhaustion experienced by healthcare providers during an outbreak can also increase the risk of human errors, which could potentially result in medical malpractice.

Overall, while changes to malpractice laws during outbreaks may be necessary to adapt to resource limitations, they can also negatively impact patients by making it more difficult to seek legal recourse for substandard medical care and increasing the risk of preventable errors.

Outbreaks can cause hospitals to be liable for medical malpractice

During a disease outbreak, hospitals may face financial repercussions if they are found liable for medical malpractice. While hospitals are always responsible for providing quality care to their patients, an outbreak can strain resources and compromise patient safety, increasing the risk of medical errors and malpractice.

When an outbreak occurs, hospitals may need to adapt to a crisis standard of care, focusing on addressing the immediate needs of a large number of patients rather than providing the best outcomes for individuals. This deviation from conventional standards of care can lead to the suspension of preventive and elective procedures, resulting in the progression of serious conditions that could have been treated earlier.

In the context of an outbreak, hospitals may be particularly vulnerable to allegations of medical malpractice if they fail to maintain reasonable safety standards, adhere to proper hygiene and sanitation protocols, or obtain informed consent from patients. For example, during the COVID-19 pandemic, hospitals faced challenges in preventing the transmission of the virus due to frequent changes in complicated guidelines, and this could have increased the risk of infections spreading within healthcare facilities.

Furthermore, outbreaks can exacerbate staffing shortages as healthcare workers become sick or are required to quarantine. This can lead to diagnostic errors, missed or delayed diagnoses, and treatment delays, which may cause harm to patients and potentially result in malpractice claims. Additionally, the high demand for nurses during outbreaks can create staffing disparities between hospitals, with some offering sign-on bonuses and pay increases, leaving other hospitals severely understaffed.

To mitigate the risk of liability, hospitals must ensure they are providing the best possible care within the constraints of the crisis. This includes maintaining thorough documentation, obtaining informed consent, and adhering to accepted safety, hygiene, and sanitation standards. While hospitals may not be held liable for infections that occur due to unforeseen circumstances, negligence or breaches in the standard of care can result in malpractice claims.

Tariff-related import expenses can increase hospital costs

Tariff-related import expenses can significantly impact hospital costs and their ability to deliver high-quality patient care. In April 2025, President Trump announced a new trade policy, including a baseline 10% tariff on imports from all countries, with higher rates for nations deemed to have excessive trade barriers. While the policy aims to strengthen the US economy, its consequences for the healthcare sector are expected to be far-reaching.

Medical supplies, such as surgical gowns, masks, devices, and information technology equipment, often account for 20% or more of a hospital's expenses. With tariffs affecting imports from China, a major producer of medical supplies and devices, hospitals face the challenge of elevated costs. The impact is twofold: firstly, hospitals may struggle to absorb the increased costs without passing them on to patients, and secondly, they may experience reduced choices in suppliers and limited access to certain products.

The tariffs on imports from China, which can be as high as 125%, cover a range of medical supplies and devices used daily in hospitals. This includes critical items such as blood pressure cuffs, sterile drapes, anesthesia instruments, needles, syringes, and pulse oximeters. Additionally, most protective gear used by healthcare workers, including N95 respirators and plastic gloves, is manufactured in China, making the industry heavily reliant on imports from this country.

The impact of these tariffs on the healthcare sector is expected to be immediate and detrimental to hospitals' financial positions. Hospitals may need to explore creative ways to cut other expenses to offset the increased costs of imports. Building a resilient and efficient supply chain is crucial to mitigating the impact of tariffs. Healthcare leaders should examine their supply chains, identify vulnerabilities, and assess alternatives to minimize the negative financial consequences of these tariff-related import expenses.

Frequently asked questions