Non-Profit Hospitals: Where Does The Money Come From?

Non-profit hospitals are funded by charity, religion, or research and educational funds, and are exempt from paying federal, state, and local property taxes. They rely on financial reserves to maintain stability and support growth. Non-profit hospitals must invest any profits back into the community, which can include facility improvements or paying executive salaries. In recent years, some non-profit hospitals have been criticized for reducing staff, demanding payment from patients who qualify for charity care, and shifting services from low-income to high-income neighborhoods. Despite this, studies show that non-profit and for-profit hospitals spend similar portions of their expenses on charity care.

Non-profit hospitals' spending on charity care decreased from 2012 to 2019

Non-profit hospitals are those that must invest any profits back into the community. They are exempt from paying most federal and state taxes and can receive tax-deductible contributions. However, there is an expectation that they will direct proceeds to community benefit. Non-profit hospitals focus on offering services that benefit the community, such as home healthcare, emergency psychiatric services, drug addiction recovery, and trauma wards.

Nonprofit hospitals have seen substantial growth in operating profits and cash reserves, but spending on charity care has decreased. A study found that the mean operating profits for nonprofit hospitals grew from $43 million in 2012 to $58.6 million by 2019, while mean cash reserve balances increased from $133.3 million to $224.3 million. However, spending on charity care dropped during that time period, from $6.7 million in 2012 to $6.4 million. Nonprofit hospitals' spending on charity care decreased from $6.65 million in 2012 to $6.36 million in 2019, while for-profit hospitals increased their charity care spending from $2.29 million to $6.30 million during the same period.

There are several potential explanations for the decrease in charity care spending by nonprofit hospitals. Firstly, some nonprofit hospitals may be reducing staff, demanding payment from patients who qualify for charity care, and shifting services from low-income to high-income neighborhoods. Additionally, some nonprofit hospitals may not expect significant oversight of their charity care practices from government regulators. Another factor could be the limited sources of funding for nonprofit hospitals, which may impact their ability to maintain financial stability and support their growth. Nonprofit hospitals may also have lower ratios of charity care to total expenses than for-profit hospitals, as they have fewer incentives to provide charity care in the form of tax deductions.

The decrease in charity care spending by nonprofit hospitals has raised concerns among critics and policymakers. Some argue that nonprofit hospitals should increase their spending on charity care, especially when compared to their high profits. There are also concerns about whether requirements for hospitals to provide satisfactory community benefits are being adequately enforced.

While the decrease in charity care spending by nonprofit hospitals is a concern, it is important to note that hospital charity care programs are a lifeline for many uninsured and underinsured patients struggling with medical debt. These programs provide free or discounted medical care to patients who cannot afford it, which can help protect undocumented and lawfully present immigrants from high medical costs.

Non-profit hospitals are exempt from most federal and state taxes

Non-profit hospitals have two main sources of funding: revenue from operations and investments, and borrowed funds through debt issuance or other forms of borrowing. They are exempt from paying most federal, state, and local taxes, including property taxes, and can issue tax-exempt bonds and receive tax-deductible contributions. This tax exemption is based on the expectation that they will direct proceeds to community benefit and reinvest profits into the community, such as through facility improvements or paying executive salaries.

While non-profit hospitals must compensate their executives, the amount of revenue directed towards executive compensation varies. Some non-profit hospitals with revenues ranging from $3.1 billion to $5.5 billion allocated an average of 0.64% of revenue to executive compensation. However, other hospitals may allocate a higher percentage, with some top executives earning millions of dollars annually.

Non-profit hospitals have access to limited sources of funding and rely on financial reserves to maintain financial stability and support growth. These reserves are essential during difficult times and can improve credit ratings, making it easier to borrow funds at more affordable interest rates. While non-profit hospitals may receive substantial tax breaks, some experts question whether their community investments and charity care justify their tax-exempt status. According to a report, 72% of private non-profit hospitals spent less on community health investments than they received in tax breaks in 2018.

Non-profit hospitals often provide services that may not be desirable for for-profit hospitals due to smaller profit margins. These services include home healthcare, emergency psychiatric services, drug addiction recovery, and trauma wards. Non-profit hospitals are more likely to offer services that tend to lose money but are highly valuable, such as burn units, hospice care, substance use treatment, and psychiatric care. They focus more on patient needs than profit-making when deciding which services to offer.

Non-profit hospitals may rely on philanthropic donations and government grants

Non-profit hospitals are exempt from paying most federal and state taxes and can receive tax-deductible contributions. However, they are expected to direct proceeds to community benefit. Non-profit hospitals may rely on philanthropic donations and government grants to fund their operations and community initiatives.

Philanthropic donations can come from individuals or corporations and are typically driven by relationships and strategic projects. For example, donations might be sought for a specific project, such as building a new wing or acquiring new technology. Non-profit hospitals may also receive planned gifts, which are non-cash contributions made through financial planning tools such as bequests, life insurance, or retirement plans. These donations can be essential in helping hospitals achieve their strategic goals and providing community benefits.

Government grants are another source of funding for non-profit hospitals. Various organizations offer grants to support sustainable and scalable solutions in healthcare, with a focus on community education, activation, and climate solutions. For instance, the Cisco Foundation provides grants for developing curricular initiatives to spur community engagement and collective action on environmental issues. Non-profit hospitals can also receive grants from private funders, with amounts typically ranging from $20,000 to $25,000.

While non-profit hospitals rely on these funding sources, there is scrutiny regarding their community benefit and charity care. Some non-profit hospitals have been criticized for not providing charity care commensurate with their tax exemptions. Policymakers are exploring ways to measure and incentivize community benefits, including charity care, to ensure that non-profit hospitals fulfill their community obligations.

Non-profit hospitals must invest profits into the community

Non-profit hospitals have an obligation to invest profits back into the community. This can include facility improvements, paying executive salaries, and funding community initiatives. Non-profit hospitals are exempt from paying most federal and state taxes, and they can receive tax-deductible contributions, so they are expected to direct proceeds to community benefit.

While non-profit hospitals are not obligated to shareholders, they still need to maintain financial reserves to ensure they can meet their obligations during difficult times. These reserves can help improve a hospital's credit rating, making it easier to borrow money for facility and technology investments. Non-profit hospitals may also generate funds through philanthropy, though most do not have the capabilities for significant fundraising efforts.

There has been some criticism of non-profit hospitals, with questions raised about whether their community investments and charity care justify their tax-exempt status. Some non-profit hospitals have been accused of reducing staff, demanding payment from patients who qualify for charity care, and shifting services from low-income to high-income neighborhoods. However, non-profit hospitals are more likely to offer services that tend to lose money but are highly valuable, such as burn units, hospice care, substance use treatment, and psychiatric care.

Despite the criticism, the number of for-profit hospitals in America is growing each year, and more non-profit hospitals are exploring potential transitions to an investor-owned financial model. Non-profit hospitals must strike a balance between financial sustainability and fulfilling their mission of serving the community.

Non-profit hospitals are more likely to offer services that lose money

Non-profit hospitals have the primary goal of delivering high-quality care to patients, and they are exempt from paying most federal and state taxes. They are also more likely to offer services that lose money, such as emergency psychiatric services, drug addiction recovery, trauma wards, and neonatal intensive care units. These services tend to provide smaller profit margins, making them less desirable for for-profit hospitals, which tend to prioritize profitable services like heart surgery. Non-profit hospitals may also be more responsive to community feedback and offer a wider range of services, including those that don't generate significant income. They rely on limited sources of funding, including revenue from operations, investments, and borrowing, as well as tax exemptions, philanthropic donations, and government grants. Non-profit hospitals are expected to invest profits back into the community, which can include facility improvements or salaries.

While the quality of care may not differ significantly between non-profit and for-profit hospitals, the latter faces pressure to maximize shareholder returns and may prioritize revenue-generating services. For-profit hospitals rely on investments, patient fees, and insurance reimbursements, and they may be more likely to invest in modern technology and facilities for treating expensive conditions.

Some reports suggest that non-profit hospitals are driving up the cost of healthcare due to their political influence and lobbying power. They benefit from tax exemptions and funnel profits into equipment, buildings, and lobbying activities, contributing to the rising cost of hospital services. However, non-profit hospitals also play a crucial role in providing charity care, especially for those who cannot afford insurance or access modern treatments at for-profit hospitals.

In summary, non-profit hospitals are more likely to offer services that lose money because of their focus on community benefit and their obligation to reinvest profits. While this may result in limited access to the latest technology and treatments, it ensures that essential services are provided to those in need, even if they are not profitable.

Frequently asked questions