Doctor's Hospital Privileges: When And Why They're Revoked

Hospital privileges are crucial for doctors as they allow them to treat patients and perform procedures within hospital settings. Doctors can lose these privileges for various reasons, including unprofessional behaviour, substance abuse, criminal charges, failure to maintain credentials or meet practice standards, and providing poor quality of care. Hospitals typically follow a review process, allowing doctors to challenge decisions and seek legal representation. Understanding the reasons for privilege loss is essential for physicians to protect their careers and take appropriate action.

Unprofessional behaviour

Being impaired by alcohol, recreational drugs, or misusing medications while on duty is an extreme risk to patient safety and is considered unprofessional conduct. Healthcare professionals have an ethical duty to self-report any conditions or impairments that might impact their ability to practice safely. Failing to disclose active addictions or health issues that could compromise patient care is a violation.

The negative impacts of unprofessional behaviour can be far-reaching, contributing to a culture of blame and the normalisation of negative behaviours within organisational cultures at hospitals. It can also lead to increased staff burnout, absences, resignations, and even bullying, which has financial implications for healthcare institutions.

Poor treatment quality

Maintaining a high level of care is paramount not just for the patient’s health and well-being but also for the hospital’s reputation and liability coverage. Documented issues in quality of care can pose a serious risk to the hospital and the doctor, and is therefore grounds for loss or restriction of privileges.

Negligence or malpractice are serious accusations with dire implications. They could be potential grounds for a lawsuit and the loss of clinical privileges. A physician may also lose their privileges if they fail to maintain the credentials required by the hospital or do not adhere to hospital practice standards. For instance, a physician must maintain an active license and malpractice insurance and comply with certain generally accepted standards of practice.

A physician's behaviour towards colleagues or patients becoming unruly or unprofessional is also grounds for losing hospital privileges and potential termination if the physician is employed by the hospital. A health care entity may also terminate a physician's contract for causes relating to poor patient care, resulting in the loss of the practitioner's network participation.

Substance abuse

Hospitals and healthcare organizations have a duty to ensure that physicians possess the mental and physical health required to provide competent professional services. Substance abuse can impair a doctor's judgment and ability to practice medicine safely and effectively, leading to potential harm to patients. As a result, hospitals may consider a physician's substance abuse issues when determining their fitness to practice medicine and whether to grant or revoke their hospital privileges.

Hospital privileges are important for doctors as they authorize them to admit patients and practice at a specific hospital or facility. Admitting privileges, telemedicine privileges, and surgical privileges are some examples of the different types of hospital privileges. When it comes to substance abuse, hospitals typically include requirements in their medical staff bylaws, which may also enable them to request treatment records of practitioners with substance abuse issues.

The Federation of State Medical Boards (FSMB) mandates that doctors must not use alcohol or other substances when treating patients. If a doctor is found to be addicted to alcohol or drugs, their medical license can be revoked. State medical licensing boards play a crucial role in overseeing physicians' licenses and ensuring patient safety. Hospitals also have intervention committees to address substance abuse issues among medical staff.

The Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) protects the confidentiality of health information. However, physicians must grant the release of mental health and substance abuse treatment records to licensing boards or hospitals, waiving their HIPAA privacy protections. This can create a dilemma for doctors seeking treatment for substance abuse, as they may be reluctant to disclose their issues due to concerns about the impact on their medical licenses and hospital privileges.

Criminal charges

Hospital privileges are authorizations given by a hospital that allow a doctor to practice medicine and treat patients within that hospital's facility. These privileges are important, especially to medical specialties that perform most of their services in a hospital setting, such as anesthesiologists, general surgeons, and cardiologists.

Hospital privileges may be revoked for a number of reasons, including criminal charges. If a physician's behavior becomes unruly or unprofessional, this can be grounds for loss of hospital privileges and potential termination if the physician is employed by the hospital. Hospitals may also revoke privileges if there are documented issues in the quality of care, as this poses a serious risk to the hospital's reputation and liability coverage.

In the case of criminal charges, a hospital may choose to revoke a doctor's privileges if the charges are related to healthcare. For example, federal or state healthcare-related criminal convictions, such as malpractice or negligence, would likely result in the loss of hospital privileges. Hospitals are required to report clinical privileges actions taken against physicians when those actions meet certain criteria, such as when the physician's conduct adversely affects or could adversely affect the health or welfare of a patient.

If a doctor faces criminal charges, they should seek legal counsel to understand their rights and options. An attorney can help navigate the process and potentially challenge the revocation of hospital privileges. It is important to note that hospitals generally have provisions in their medical staff bylaws that outline the process and grounds for recommending and taking action against a physician's clinical privileges.

Lack of credentials

Hospital privileges are a crucial part of a doctor's career, allowing them to treat patients and perform procedures within hospital settings. The loss of these privileges can be detrimental to a doctor's ability to practice medicine and can also damage their professional reputation.

Doctors are required to maintain an active license, malpractice insurance, and board certifications. Failure to renew these credentials or meet hospital-specific compliance requirements can result in the suspension or revocation of hospital privileges. Hospitals have specific privileging criteria that outline the requirements for doctors to obtain and maintain hospital privileges. These criteria typically include factors such as documented training, experience, and current clinical competence. It is important for doctors to be familiar with their institution's privileging process and bylaws to ensure they meet the necessary standards.

In addition to maintaining their credentials, doctors must also adhere to hospital practice standards and maintain a high level of care. Issues in the quality of care, including negligence or malpractice, can pose a serious risk to both the hospital and the doctor, leading to the loss or restriction of privileges. Hospitals closely monitor patient outcomes, adherence to protocols, and feedback from staff and patients to assess a physician's performance.

To maintain their hospital privileges, doctors should regularly update their medical knowledge, follow safety protocols, and practice defensively to reduce the risk of malpractice claims. Additionally, participating in ongoing training and education is crucial for ensuring professional competency and maintaining hospital privileges.

Overall, the loss of hospital privileges due to a lack of credentials can have significant consequences for a doctor's career and reputation. It is important for doctors to stay up-to-date with licensing requirements, maintain their credentials, and adhere to hospital standards to avoid facing disciplinary action and losing their privileges.

Frequently asked questions