Economic Impact: Hospital Utilization Explained

The economy and hospital utilization are closely linked, with economic downturns often leading to a decrease in healthcare utilization as people put off health services to save money. This was particularly evident during the COVID-19 pandemic, when hospital admissions for acute and elective procedures dropped sharply. In addition, the economic effects of the pandemic may have further depressed the number of people seeking healthcare services. On the other hand, a strong economy can lead to increased healthcare utilization as people have more disposable income to spend on healthcare. Healthcare costs have been rising in recent years, with spending on hospital care increasing by 10.4% from 2022 to 2023. This has put pressure on employers, insurers, and patients to keep up with the rising costs. As healthcare costs continue to climb, it will be interesting to see how hospital utilization is affected and whether people will be able to access the healthcare they need.

Cost-related barriers to healthcare access

Data from the National Health Interview Survey (NHIS) reveals that in 2023, more than one in four adults (28%) reported delaying or foregoing healthcare due to cost. This figure includes skipping or delaying medical care, mental health care, dental care, and prescription medications. The impact of cost-related barriers is not evenly distributed across demographic groups. Uninsured adults, adults in worse health, and Black and Hispanic adults are more likely to face these challenges. Among non-elderly adults who visited a hospital or emergency room in 2022, 26% experienced at least one access-to-care barrier, including cost-related issues.

The consequences of cost-related barriers to healthcare access can be severe, leading to detrimental health outcomes and even loss of life. The economic implications of these barriers are also significant. As healthcare prices rise, employers often face difficult choices, including reducing wages or cutting jobs to offset the increased costs. This results in a downward spiral, where higher healthcare costs contribute to reduced wages and increased unemployment.

The COVID-19 pandemic has further highlighted the impact of cost-related barriers on healthcare utilization. During the pandemic, stay-at-home measures, concerns about infection, and hospital capacity issues led to sharp declines in healthcare utilization and spending. Even as the pandemic recedes, healthcare utilization has not rebounded to pre-pandemic levels, suggesting that some individuals may have forgone care rather than simply delayed it. Federal assistance has provided temporary relief to hospitals and healthcare providers, but the long-term financial impact on these institutions remains uncertain.

Addressing cost-related barriers to healthcare access is critical for improving health outcomes and reducing the economic burden on individuals, employers, and the government. While initiatives like the Affordable Care Act (ACA) and Medicaid expansion have helped, more comprehensive solutions are needed to ensure equitable access to healthcare for all.

Impact of economic downturns on hospital utilisation

Economic downturns can have a significant impact on hospital utilisation, with a range of factors influencing the extent and nature of this impact. Firstly, during economic recessions, hospital utilisation may decrease as individuals may postpone or avoid seeking medical care due to financial constraints. This was particularly evident during the COVID-19 pandemic, where concerns about hospital capacity, the risk of infection, and economic hardships led to a sharp decline in hospital admissions and elective procedures.

Secondly, economic downturns can affect the healthcare workforce. During challenging economic periods, healthcare providers may experience financial strain, potentially resulting in reduced staffing levels or limited resources, which can further decrease hospital utilisation. Conversely, economic downturns can lead to increased demand for healthcare services, especially among low-income individuals who may have greater health needs. This can result in higher utilisation of emergency departments and hospital services, as observed among Medicaid beneficiaries.

Additionally, economic factors interact with other social determinants of health, such as education, community safety, and access to adequate housing and nutritious food. These factors collectively influence an individual's health status and their propensity to use healthcare services. For example, during economic downturns, individuals may experience housing instability or food insecurity, which can exacerbate health conditions and increase the need for medical care.

Furthermore, economic downturns can impact the development and diffusion of healthcare technologies. On the one hand, a weak economy may hinder investment in healthcare innovation, slowing the development of new technologies that could improve hospital efficiency and patient outcomes. On the other hand, economic challenges may incentivise the adoption of cost-effective technologies, such as ambulatory surgery centres and outpatient facilities, which can enhance accessibility and reduce the average length of hospital stays.

Finally, the impact of economic downturns on hospital utilisation can be influenced by governmental and institutional responses. Federal assistance, such as grants and relief funds, can help sustain hospitals during economic crises. Conversely, reduced government spending on healthcare or cuts to health insurance coverage may further deter individuals from seeking hospital care, exacerbating the decrease in hospital utilisation.

Healthcare utilisation and socioeconomic factors

Socioeconomic factors play a significant role in healthcare utilisation, encompassing various aspects such as income, urbanisation, and individual behaviours. Firstly, income levels have a substantial impact on healthcare utilisation. Low-income individuals tend to utilise emergency and hospital services more frequently, but they also experience greater challenges in accessing timely and affordable healthcare. Adults under the poverty level often face delays or forgo medical care, prescription drugs, and dental care due to financial constraints. This results in unmet healthcare needs despite their higher utilisation of emergency services.

Urbanisation is another socioeconomic factor influencing healthcare utilisation. Communities with varying levels of urbanisation differ in their demographic, environmental, economic, and social characteristics. These characteristics are associated with specific health problems and access to care. For instance, residents' sociodemographic traits, including income, education, and employment status, can impact their healthcare utilisation. Additionally, urban areas may offer a wider range of healthcare services, making them more accessible to residents.

Individual behaviours, as identified by the World Health Organization, also play a role in healthcare utilisation. These behaviours include smoking, physical activity levels, dietary habits, and other lifestyle choices that can lead to health conditions requiring medical attention. Furthermore, socioeconomic factors such as education, economic stability, community safety, access to healthy food, and housing influence health outcomes and, consequently, healthcare utilisation.

During economic downturns, healthcare utilisation patterns may change. For example, the COVID-19 pandemic led to a sharp decline in healthcare utilisation and spending due to stay-at-home measures, infection risks, and concerns over hospital capacity. However, it is important to note that healthcare utilisation did not rebound immediately after the pandemic, suggesting that some care may have been foregone rather than delayed. Economic factors, such as income and employment stability, can influence individuals' decisions to seek healthcare services.

Healthcare utilisation also varies across different population groups. For instance, white women are more likely to have outpatient surgery than women of other races or ethnicities. Additionally, individuals with Medicaid, who are often poor and disabled, tend to rely more on emergency departments due to limited access to ambulatory care. These disparities in healthcare utilisation highlight the impact of socioeconomic factors and the unequal access to healthcare services among different demographic groups.

Healthcare utilisation and urbanisation

Urbanisation has a significant impact on healthcare utilisation. As the world's population increasingly concentrates in cities, with estimates suggesting that 70% of people will live in urban areas by 2050, the relationship between urbanisation and healthcare utilisation becomes ever more critical.

Several factors influence the impact of urbanisation on healthcare utilisation. Firstly, the economic status of a city is a key determinant of health outcomes for its population. The rate of economic investment, a measure of urbanisation, affects the socioeconomic status of a city, which in turn influences the health status of its residents. Higher economic investment can lead to improved access to healthcare services and better health outcomes.

Secondly, the characteristics of the urban population play a crucial role. Population density, a common measure of urbanicity, can impact health outcomes. For example, low socioeconomic status groups, often associated with poverty and poorer health, are prevalent in urban areas. Additionally, certain demographic factors, such as age and income, influence healthcare utilisation.

The availability and accessibility of healthcare services in urban areas are also essential considerations. As medical technologies become more portable and affordable, complex procedures can be performed outside of hospitals, increasing accessibility for urban residents. However, disparities exist, as certain groups, such as racial and ethnic minorities, may face barriers to accessing these services.

Furthermore, urban planning and development models are crucial in managing the challenges posed by urbanisation. Public health is a core issue, and initiatives like the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) aim to address health inequalities and social and economic impacts within cities. SDG 11, for instance, focuses on making cities inclusive and sustainable to manage demographic and epidemiological transitions effectively.

In conclusion, urbanisation has a complex relationship with healthcare utilisation. While increased urbanisation may lead to greater utilisation of health services, the impact on health outcomes depends on various factors, including economic investment, population characteristics, and the availability and accessibility of healthcare services. Standardised measures of urbanicity and multidisciplinary studies are necessary to fully understand and address the challenges posed by urbanisation on healthcare systems.

Federal assistance and hospital finances

During the coronavirus pandemic, hospitals and healthcare providers qualified for various types of federal assistance. Notably, hospitals received grants from the $178 billion provider relief fund distributed by the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS). While federal assistance has helped hospitals remain temporarily sustained, there are concerns about the long-term impact on hospital finances once this support ends.

Federal law does not outline the criteria for determining eligibility for financial assistance, but several states have laws and regulations that do. For example, Washington State mandates hospitals to offer free care to patients with family incomes below 100% of the federal poverty level (FPL) and discounted care for those with incomes up to 200% of the FPL. In New Jersey and Massachusetts, the income threshold for free care eligibility is 200% of the FPL, and New Jersey also offers financial assistance to low-income uninsured or underinsured residents.

Nonprofit hospitals receive significant federal and state tax exemptions, with total tax relief estimated at $24.6 billion in 2011. These tax exemptions are intended to fund, at least in part, the financial assistance and community benefits provided by hospitals. Some states provide additional incentives, such as property, income, and sales tax exemptions for nonprofit hospitals that offer financial assistance.

The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) defines "charity care," also known as "financial assistance," as "free or discounted health services provided to persons who meet the organization's eligibility criteria for financial assistance and are unable to pay for all or a portion of the services." Federal regulations require nonprofit hospitals to provide some level of charity care as a condition of their tax-exempt status. Hospitals must establish a Financial Assistance Policy (FAP) that outlines eligibility criteria, levels of assistance, and application processes. However, gaps in federal regulation and weak oversight may result in hospitals providing varying levels of charity care.

Frequently asked questions