The High Cost Of Private Healthcare In India

India's private health sector is booming, but it is also extremely expensive. Private hospitals in India are six times more expensive than government institutions, with treatment costing thousands in the former and lakhs in the latter. This has led to over 40% of hospitalised patients having to borrow money or sell assets, including inherited property and farmland, to cover their medical expenses. This has also driven 25% of farmers below the poverty line. Private hospitals in India are largely unregulated, with no standardisation of quality or costs. This has led to a situation where only the richest Indians can afford treatment at these hospitals.

Private hospitals cost six times more than government hospitals

The cost of healthcare in India varies significantly between public and private providers. Private hospitals in India are significantly more expensive than government-run institutions. A study by the Union Ministry of Statistics and Programme Implementation found that hospitalisation in a private hospital costs six times more than in a government hospital. The average expenditure per person for a hospital stay was Rs 4,452 in a government hospital and Rs 31,845 in a private facility.

The study, titled 'Key indicators of social consumption in India: Health', compared the costs incurred in government and private institutions across nine categories of ailments. The cost difference was even more pronounced for musculoskeletal and cardiovascular conditions, where treatment in private hospitals was eight times more expensive.

The reasons for the cost discrepancy are multifaceted. Private hospitals have higher operating costs due to their investment in advanced technology and resources. Additionally, the private healthcare sector in India has been largely unregulated, with no standardisation of quality or costs, allowing them to set higher prices. The success of private hospitals in providing high-quality care has attracted many Indians, despite the significantly higher expenses.

On the other hand, government hospitals operate with low manpower and technological support, often resulting in long waiting times. The lack of skilled specialists in government hospitals further contributes to the preference for private healthcare. Ideally, a substantial proportion of the population who cannot afford private treatment should be catered to by government hospitals, but this often does not happen, leading to a reliance on private healthcare.

To mitigate the financial burden of healthcare, individuals in India often turn to health insurance plans. These plans can provide cashless hospitalisation, covering expenses related to both pre and post-hospitalisation care, and protecting individuals from medical inflation. However, this also shifts the financial burden to insurance companies, who then charge market-driven premium amounts to their customers.

Private hospitals are unregulated, with no standardisation of quality or costs

Private hospitals in India are largely unregulated, with no standardisation of quality or costs. This means that the prices of medical services can vary widely across different private hospitals, and there is no guarantee of consistent quality. While some private hospitals in India offer excellent medical care, the lack of regulation can also lead to issues such as unnecessary diagnostic tests and procedures being performed, as patients suspect.

The cost of private healthcare in India is significantly higher than that of public healthcare. Hospitalisation in a private hospital can cost up to six times more than in a government institution. For instance, a study by the Union Ministry of Statistics and Programme Implementation found that the average expenditure per person for a hospital stay was Rs 4,452 in a government hospital and Rs 31,845 at a private facility. This disparity is partly due to the lack of standardisation in private hospital costs and the fact that private providers do not receive the same government subsidies as public facilities.

The high costs of private healthcare in India have significant implications for patients. Many individuals are forced to borrow money or sell assets, including inherited property and farmland, to cover medical expenses. This has driven 25% of farmers below the poverty line. The situation is further exacerbated by the shortcomings of the public healthcare system, which struggles with long waiting times, inadequate manpower, and a lack of technological resources. As a result, citizens often opt for private hospitals despite the higher costs.

The Indian government has, to an extent, encouraged the growth of the private healthcare sector through various subsidies and incentives. However, this has come at the cost of public healthcare, which has suffered from a lack of investment and attention. While the private sector now accounts for 82% of outpatient visits, 58% of inpatient expenditure, and 40% of institutional births, the public sector continues to lag, with citizens facing interminable waits in often dirty surroundings.

To address these issues, some have suggested imposing greater social accountability on private providers, making a certain proportion of their services available to the poor. This could help ensure that quality healthcare is accessible to all, regardless of income. However, others worry that increased regulation may simply lead to bureaucratic delays and corruption.

Private hospitals are chosen over public hospitals due to long wait times and poor conditions

Private hospitals in India are significantly more expensive than public hospitals. A study by the Union Ministry of Statistics and Programme Implementation found that hospitalisation in a private hospital costs six times more than in a government institution. The study, which looked at nine categories of ailments, found that the cost went up to eight times more in private hospitals for musculoskeletal and cardiovascular conditions.

Despite the higher costs, many people in India opt for private hospitals over public hospitals due to long wait times and poor conditions in the latter. A countrywide survey on healthcare access revealed that an increasing proportion of people are using private healthcare facilities, despite the much higher costs in the private sector. The primary reasons for this choice are the absence of doctors and dissatisfaction with quality standards in public hospitals. Long waiting periods, the non-availability of medicines, and a lack of diagnostic facilities are also key factors in people's decisions to choose private over public healthcare.

A study conducted by the IMS Institute for Healthcare Informatics in over 14,000 households across 12 states found that between 85% and 90% of patients are willing to shift from the private to the public sector if the situation in public healthcare facilities improves. This indicates that people's preference for private hospitals is not due to a lack of awareness of the cost difference but rather because of the issues with access and quality in public healthcare.

The cost of healthcare in India has been rising, with health inflation impacting both private and public healthcare sectors. However, the impact is more visible in the private hospital admission rate, as the government hospitals operate with low manpower and technological support. This has resulted in long waiting lines in public hospitals, further pushing people towards private healthcare.

To mitigate the financial burden of healthcare, individuals in India can invest in comprehensive health insurance plans that cover both pre and post-hospitalisation expenses. Such insurance plans can provide peace of mind and protect individuals from the high costs of healthcare, whether in the private or public sector.

Private hospitals deliver about 80% of outpatient care and 60% of inpatient care

Private healthcare in India is significantly more expensive than public healthcare. A study by the Union ministry of statistics and programme implementation found that hospitalisation in a private hospital costs six times more than in a government institution. The average expenditure per person for a hospital stay was Rs 4,452 in a government hospital and Rs 31,845 at a private facility. This difference is partly due to the fact that public hospitals operate with low manpower and technological support, and long waiting times.

The high cost of private healthcare in India can be mitigated by investing in a comprehensive health insurance plan. These plans can cover both pre- and post-hospitalisation expenses, protecting individuals from the financial burden of medical treatment. Some insurance plans even offer cashless hospitalisation, where the patient does not have to make any payments beyond operational expenses.

However, it is important to note that public and private health insurance in India typically do not cover outpatient care. This means that patients have to pay out-of-pocket expenses for outpatient treatment, which can be substantially higher in the private sector.

The private healthcare sector's dominance in India has been largely overlooked by policy planners, despite its ever-increasing role in the country's health system. This has resulted in a heavy burden on private households, which account for 72% of total health spending.

Private hospitalisation costs in urban areas are more expensive than in rural areas

Private hospitalisation costs in urban areas of India are significantly more expensive than in rural areas. This disparity in pricing between urban and rural regions is not unique to private hospitals, as public hospitals also exhibit a similar trend. However, the difference in costs between private and public hospitals is much more pronounced.

In urban areas, private hospitals are favoured over public hospitals, with 61.4% of hospitalisations occurring in private institutions, compared to 35.3% in rural areas. This preference for private healthcare in urban regions can be attributed to various factors, including the shortcomings of the public healthcare system. The public healthcare sector in India is often characterised by long waiting times, inadequate infrastructure, and a lack of essential medicines and tests, prompting patients to seek alternative options.

The cost of treatment in private hospitals in India's urban areas can be up to 20 times higher than in public hospitals. A day in an ICU ward, for example, can cost Rs. 30,000 in a private hospital, compared to Rs. 1,500 in a public hospital. The reasons for the high costs in private hospitals are multifaceted. Firstly, the private healthcare sector in India has become increasingly corporatised, with large corporations and wealthy individuals establishing hospitals that cater to the wealthy. These hospitals often employ foreign-trained doctors and utilise advanced technology, driving up costs.

Another factor contributing to the high costs in private hospitals is the lack of regulation. These hospitals operate largely without standardised quality or pricing controls, allowing them to set prices that only the wealthiest can afford. Additionally, the private sector has been criticised for allegedly performing unnecessary diagnostic tests and surgical procedures, further inflating expenses.

The rising costs of healthcare in India have significant implications for patients. Many individuals are forced to borrow money or sell assets, including inherited property and farmland, to cover medical expenses. This financial burden can be devastating, with 25% of farmers being driven below the poverty line due to healthcare costs. To mitigate these financial risks, investing in comprehensive health insurance plans that cover both pre and post-hospitalisation expenses is strongly recommended.

Frequently asked questions