Texas Hospitals: Overcrowding And Capacity Concerns

Texas hospitals have been in the news for various reasons over the past few years. In 2020, Houston's largest hospital, Texas Medical Center, made headlines when its ICU was 97% full, with 27% of patients contracting COVID-19. This raised concerns about the state's ability to manage the pandemic. Additionally, Texas hospitals have faced challenges due to power outages, staffing shortages, and controversial executive orders regarding patient citizenship and immigration status tracking. There are also concerns about the potential closure of rural hospitals, which could leave patients without timely access to emergency care. Despite these challenges, hospitals like Houston Methodist have been recognized for their excellence, offering advanced clinical care and patient experience.

Texas hospitals at risk of closing due to low reimbursement rates

Texas hospitals are at risk of closing due to low reimbursement rates, threatening critical care in the state. According to a report by the Center for Healthcare Quality and Payment Reform (CHQPR), Texas is one of the states with the most hospitals at risk of closure, with more than 20 medical facilities in danger of shutting down. This issue is not unique to Texas, as financial challenges are putting pressure on small hospitals across the country. About 768 rural hospitals in the US are at risk of closing, with 315 at "immediate risk" of doing so within the next three years.

Low reimbursement rates from Medicare and Medicaid coverage are significant factors contributing to the financial strain on these hospitals. Urban hospitals tend to receive higher reimbursement rates from patients with private insurance, which often pays more. The proposed cuts to Medicaid by Republicans could leave millions of people uninsured and further strain rural hospitals. According to the Center for American Progress, nearly one-third of rural hospitals are already at risk of closing due to sustained financial losses and low cash reserves.

The closure of rural hospitals in Texas would create significant access problems for patients, especially in remote areas where alternative providers may not be readily available. It can also have economic implications, as people may be less likely to live in areas without access to healthcare, potentially leading to a decrease in per capita income. The impact of hospital closures extends beyond emergency and primary care, affecting obstetrics, mental health services, and long-term treatment as well.

To address the financial challenges faced by rural hospitals, grants from the government and local tax revenues have been crucial in helping some hospitals stay operational. However, these funds are not guaranteed, and sustained financial losses continue to threaten the viability of rural healthcare facilities in Texas and beyond. The situation highlights the need for significant changes in the methods and amounts used by insurance companies and public insurance programs to reimburse rural hospitals for their services.

Texas Medical Center ICU beds at 97% capacity in 2020

In June 2020, the Texas Medical Center (TMC) in Houston, the self-declared largest medical complex in the world, reported that its ICU beds were at 97% capacity. The normal occupancy rate for the ICU beds is between 70% and 80%. At the time, 27% of patients occupying the ICU beds had contracted COVID-19, and coronavirus hospitalizations had doubled in Texas over the previous month, and tripled in the Greater Houston area.

The Texas Medical Center expected that all of its beds, including backup beds added during spikes, would be full within the next two weeks. In response, the center activated its emergency plan to increase the number of ICU beds from 1,462 to 2,649. However, it anticipated that even these additional beds would be filled within two weeks.

On June 25, the Texas Medical Center reported that its ICU was at 100% occupancy. For three days, it stopped reporting intensive care unit bed capacity data, leading to concerns about its ability to manage a projected spike in cases. During this period, Texas Gov. Greg Abbott ordered hospitals in some areas, including Houston, to halt elective surgical procedures to preserve ICU beds for COVID-19 patients.

Despite the high ICU occupancy rates, Dr. McDeavitt, senior vice president and dean of Clinical Affairs for Baylor College of Medicine, stated that there was "no crisis of beds." He asserted that they had plenty of ICU capacity and could handle twice as many COVID-19 patients in the ICUs. Instead, he expressed greater concern about the rising "positivity rate," which indicated an increasing proportion of people testing positive for COVID-19.

Texas hospitals required to ask patients about citizenship

In November 2024, Texas hospitals were required to ask patients about their citizenship status as part of an executive order by Governor Greg Abbott. The Texas Health and Human Services Commission (HHSC) issued the guidance, which stated that hospital providers must ask each patient during the intake process whether they are a citizen or an alien lawfully or unlawfully present in the United States. The order does not require patients to provide this information, nor are there any legal, financial, or healthcare consequences for declining to answer.

Abbott's stated reason for the order was to collect data on the costs of caring for undocumented patients, with the aim of having the federal government reimburse Texas for the care provided. He claimed that Texas absorbs a large percentage of the costs associated with medical care for people who are not lawfully in the country. According to the Texas Hospital Association, five million Texans have no insurance.

Immigration advocates and community health groups raised concerns that the order would lead to a decline in the utilization of healthcare services by undocumented immigrants, similar to what had been observed in Florida. They worried that this would discourage a population that already experiences disproportionate health disparities from receiving preventive healthcare, emergency care, and other essential services.

In response to the order, the League of United Latin American Citizens (LULAC) released an updated "Know Your Rights" guideline, reminding people that access to medical care is a lawful right in a medical emergency and that Texas hospitals would continue to treat patients regardless of their legal status. Local hospitals also stressed that they would not deny medical help to anyone, regardless of their ability to answer the citizenship question or their legal status.

The Children's Defense Fund-Texas (CDF-TX) expressed deep concern about the impact of the order on Texas children and families, particularly given that Texas already has the nation's highest rate of uninsured children. They believe that everyone deserves access to life-saving medical care, regardless of their immigration status or place of birth, and that providing preventative care to all is in the best interest of all Texans.

Texas hospitals denying care to pregnant patients due to abortion laws

Texas hospitals have been denying care to pregnant women due to the state's abortion laws, which have made it increasingly difficult for pregnant women to access healthcare. The state's abortion restrictions, which include a ban on most abortions after six weeks of pregnancy, have led to hospitals turning away pregnant patients or delaying their care, resulting in complications. Doctors in Texas face severe penalties, including six-figure fines and jail time, if they perform abortions that are not permitted under the state's abortion laws. This has created a climate of fear among medical professionals, who are unsure if they can provide treatment without violating the law.

In one example, a physician in Central Texas was allegedly instructed not to treat an ectopic pregnancy until a rupture occurred, putting the patient's health and future reproductive ability at serious risk. Ectopic pregnancies are life-threatening emergencies that require immediate treatment. Despite this, hospitals in Texas have been accused of turning away women with ectopic pregnancies, resulting in compromised fertility and even death. The Texas Medical Association (TMA) has received complaints that hospital administrators and their legal teams are preventing doctors from providing medically appropriate care to pregnant patients with complications.

The situation has led to calls for the federal government and state regulators to intervene. Two women who faced life-threatening pregnancies due to ectopic pregnancies filed complaints with the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), arguing that hospitals violated the Emergency Medical Treatment and Labor Act (EMTALA). The complaints seek to ensure that Texas hospitals provide emergency abortion care in dire situations, as required by federal law, even in states with abortion bans. The Center for Reproductive Rights is also dedicated to helping people access abortion and providing legal support when needed.

Amidst the controversy surrounding abortion laws and the impact on healthcare access, some hospitals in Texas have been recognized for their overall excellence and commitment to patient care. Houston Methodist Hospital, located in the Texas Medical Center, has been ranked among the country's top hospitals in several specialties and has been named the No. 1 hospital in Texas. The hospital boasts over 900 beds, 8,400 employees, and six Centers of Excellence, providing advanced clinical care, technology, and patient experience. However, it is important to note that the Texas Medical Center in Houston faced a challenging situation during the COVID-19 pandemic, with its ICU beds reaching 97% occupancy in June 2020, surpassing the normal occupancy rate of 70% to 80%.

Texas hospitals relying on generators due to power outages

Texas hospitals are struggling to accommodate the surge in COVID-19 patients, with Houston's largest hospital's ICU reaching 97% capacity in June 2020. The Texas Medical Center (TMC), the world's largest medical complex, predicted that all its beds would be occupied within two weeks. This crisis was exacerbated by power outages caused by Hurricane Beryl in 2024, forcing 17 hospitals in the state to rely on generators.

The Texas Department of State Health Services reported that hospitals in southeast Texas faced challenges due to Hurricane Beryl, including water and wind damage, power outages, staff shortages, and transportation issues. St. Luke's Health-Memorial Hospital in Polk County was one of the hospitals operating on generator power. Discharged patients in Houston were temporarily housed in an arena to avoid returning to homes without electricity.

The strain on hospitals in Texas is not a new issue. During an ice storm in February 2023, Texans relying on electrically powered medical equipment, such as oxygen, faced the dangerous threat of potential power outages. To address this, hospitals in Texas are required to have emergency generators that can power critical circuits for at least 96 hours. These generators are tested monthly to ensure functionality.

However, prolonged power outages can still pose significant challenges for hospitals, as seen during the February 2021 winter storm. The Southwest Texas Regional Advisory Council (STRAC) oversees 53 hospitals in south Texas and recognizes the critical need for backup power. Eric Epley, CEO of STRAC, emphasized the existence of a network of critical infrastructure fuel capacity, ensuring fuel availability for generators in hospitals.

The Texas Medical Center in Houston, with over 900 beds and 8,400 employees, has consistently been ranked among the top hospitals in the country. Despite their resources, Texas hospitals continue to face challenges due to natural disasters, pandemics, and the subsequent strain on their infrastructure and staff.

Frequently asked questions