Hospital Reimbursement: Impact And Challenges

The healthcare reimbursement system is a complex process that involves paying healthcare providers for services rendered to patients. Hospitals are reimbursed by payers, which can be insurance companies or government programs like Medicare and Medicaid. The reimbursement rates are often negotiated separately with each payer, and hospitals aim to set charges that maximize reimbursement. The primary reimbursement model is fee-for-service, where each service is billed individually based on agreed-upon rates. Healthcare reimbursement is shifting towards value-based models, where providers are paid based on the quality, not the volume, of services. This complex system is constantly evolving with policy adjustments, and hospitals must navigate insurance reimbursement complexities to ensure financial gains.

Hospitals make a profit when they spend less than the DRG payment for treating a patient

Hospitals, healthcare providers, and diagnostic labs receive reimbursement for providing medical services. The most common reimbursement method is fee-for-service (FFS), where each service is itemized and billed based on an agreed rate. The agreed rate is determined by a contracted amount that the government or private insurer has set for each service. Government payers include Medicare, Medicaid, Tricare, the Children's Health Insurance Program (CHIP), and the Veteran's Administration (VA). Private insurers include Blue Cross/Blue Shield, Aetna, and UnitedHealthcare.

Medicare's DRG (diagnosis-related group) system is called the Medicare severity diagnosis-related group (MS-DRG). It is used to determine hospital payments under the inpatient prospective payment system (IPPS). The idea behind DRGs is to ensure that Medicare reimbursements accurately reflect "the fundamental role which a hospital's case mix (the type of patients the hospital treats and the severity of their medical issues) plays in determining its costs" and the number of resources the hospital needs to treat its patients. The diagnoses used to determine the DRG are based on ICD-11 or ICD-10 codes.

DRGs have a relative weight assigned to them, with less than 1.0 being less resource-intensive and costly to treat, and more than 1.0 requiring more resources and being more expensive to treat. The higher the relative weight, the more resources are required to treat a patient with that DRG. To determine how much a hospital was reimbursed for a patient's hospitalization, one can multiply the DRG's relative weight by the hospital's base payment rate. For example, if a hospital has a base payment rate of $6,000 and a patient's DRG relative weight is 1.3, the hospital will be reimbursed $7,800 for that patient's hospitalization.

If a hospital spends less money treating a patient than the DRG payment it receives, it makes a profit. Conversely, if the hospital spends more money treating a patient than the DRG payment it receives, it loses money. Hospitals can increase their profits by discharging patients sooner, as this allows them to make money from the DRG payment. However, Medicare requires hospitals to share a portion of the DRG payment with rehabilitation or home healthcare providers if a patient is discharged early. Additionally, Medicare has implemented a system to penalize hospitals with excessive readmission rates, encouraging hospitals to have protocols in place to prevent this.

The Affordable Care Act (ACA) has also introduced Medicare payment reforms, including bundled payments and Accountable Care Organizations (ACOs), to counter the impact of reimbursement methodologies on hospitals.

Hospitals lose money when they spend more than the DRG payment

Hospitals are reimbursed for the services they provide to patients. The most common reimbursement method is fee-for-service (FFS), in which each service is itemized and billed based on an agreed rate. The FFS rate is determined by a contract between the hospital and the payer, which could be a government payer or a private insurer.

Government payers include Medicare, Medicaid, TRICARE, the Children's Health Insurance Program (CHIP), and the Veteran's Administration (VA). Private insurers include Blue Cross/Blue Shield, Aetna, and UnitedHealthcare. Medicare and Medicaid, the largest payers in the US, assign a common procedural technology (CPT) code to each service, describing the agreed-upon reimbursement cost.

Hospitals are paid based on diagnosis-related groups (DRG) that represent fixed amounts for each hospital stay. When a hospital spends less than the DRG payment, it makes a profit. However, when a hospital spends more than the DRG payment, it loses money.

Healthcare reimbursement is shifting towards value-based models, where providers are reimbursed based on the quality, not the volume, of services rendered. Payers assess quality based on patient outcomes and a provider's ability to contain costs. Providers earn more reimbursement when they can provide high-quality, low-cost care compared to peers and their benchmark data.

To maximize reimbursement, hospitals should focus on patient outcomes and streamline service delivery based on patient needs, prioritizing quality over quantity. This approach can lead to increases in efficiency and revenue for the hospital.

Hospitals are paid based on diagnosis-related groups (DRG)

Hospitals, healthcare providers, and diagnostic labs are reimbursed for the medical services they provide. The most common reimbursement method is fee-for-service (FFS), where each service is itemized and billed based on an agreed rate. However, Medicare and some private insurance companies use a diagnosis-related group (DRG) payment system.

A DRG is a way to categorize hospitalization costs based on a patient's primary and secondary diagnoses, other conditions (comorbidities), age, sex, and necessary medical procedures. This system aims to ensure patients receive the care they need without unnecessary charges. Under the DRG approach, Medicare pays hospitals a predetermined amount under the inpatient prospective payment system (IPPS). The exact payment is based on the patient's DRG, and Medicare uses the MS-DRG system for this. The MS-DRG system calculates the payment based on the patient's primary diagnosis, up to 24 secondary diagnoses, and up to 25 medical procedures.

The IPPS payment based on the Medicare DRG also covers outpatient services provided in the three days before hospitalization, which is an exception to the typical Medicare Part B coverage for outpatient services. When a patient with Medicare or private insurance is hospitalized, they are assigned a DRG code based on their condition. Each DRG has a different weight depending on the resources generally required to provide care for that category. The DRG payment amount is determined by calculating the average cost of resources needed to treat patients in that DRG, and this base rate is adjusted based on factors like the wage index for the hospital's location.

The DRG system can impact hospital finances, as hospitals make money on a hospitalization if they treat patients for less than the Medicare DRG payment and lose money if they spend more. After the MS-DRG system was implemented in 2008, Medicare reduced base payment rates due to increased hospital payment rates caused by improved coding. This reduction, along with other factors, has contributed to financial challenges and closures of hospitals, especially in rural areas.

In-network reimbursement levels are much lower than out-of-network

Hospitals, healthcare providers, and diagnostic labs receive reimbursement for providing medical services to patients. The most common reimbursement method is fee-for-service (FFS), where each service is itemized and billed based on an agreed rate. This rate is determined by a contract between the hospital and the payer, which can be a private insurance company or a government program.

In-network and out-of-network are terms used to describe the relationship between a hospital and a payer. If a hospital has a negotiated contract with a payer, it is considered in-network. Out-of-network refers to when there is no contract between the hospital and the payer. In-network reimbursement levels are typically lower than out-of-network rates. However, being in-network is still advantageous as payers often discourage their members from using out-of-network facilities.

In-network providers must accept a discounted rate for covered services under the health plan. These discounted rates are often much lower than the rates charged by out-of-network providers. Out-of-network providers can bill patients at full price, which can result in unexpected medical bills and higher out-of-pocket costs for patients.

Patients with health insurance plans that provide access to a network of in-network providers can benefit from lower healthcare expenses. These in-network providers have agreed to accept a discounted rate for their services, which helps patients save money. However, it is important to note that in-network providers may have higher copay or coinsurance amounts compared to out-of-network providers. Copay refers to a fixed amount paid for covered health services, while coinsurance is a percentage of the covered charges.

In some cases, patients may intentionally seek out-of-network care. This could be due to a lack of in-network providers in their area or the need for specialized care that is not available within their network. In these situations, patients can request an out-of-network exception from their insurer, allowing them to access out-of-network services at in-network rates.

Hospitals often receive less payment than the amount listed on their chargemaster due to negotiated discounts known as contractual adjustments

The term "contractual adjustment" refers to the negotiated discounts that hospitals offer to payers. These negotiated rates are typically lower than the chargemaster rates. Hospitals are incentivized to negotiate these rates because payers, such as insurance companies, discourage their members from using out-of-network facilities. By negotiating a contract, the hospital becomes an in-network provider and gains access to the payer's members as potential patients.

The various payer types include managed care, governmental, and self-pay/charity care. Managed care payers are third-party payers that negotiate payment rates for services provided to their member patients by the hospital. These payers include private insurance companies such as Aetna, Blue Cross Blue Shield, and UnitedHealthcare. Each hospital negotiates separate contracts with these payers, which determine how much the payer reimburses for services. For example, reimbursement for services rendered to a patient with Blue Cross PPO insurance will be based on the contract between the hospital and Blue Cross Blue Shield.

Governmental payers include Medicare, Medicaid, TRICARE, the Children's Health Insurance Program (CHIP), and the Veteran's Administration (VA). Medicare, a federally run healthcare program, sets specific service payments using a Medicare Severity Diagnostic Related Group (MS-DRG) system. This is a per-admission rate payment, meaning that Medicare pays a set rate for each admission, regardless of the hospital's chargemaster rates. For example, if hospital charges for a three-day inpatient admission total $37,000, but the associated MS-DRG payment rate is $10,000, Medicare is only required to pay $10,000.

The shift towards value-based reimbursement models further emphasizes the importance of negotiated discounts and contractual adjustments. In value-based models, hospitals and physicians are reimbursed based on the quality, rather than the volume, of services rendered. Payers assess quality based on patient outcomes and the provider's ability to contain costs. Hospitals that can provide high-quality, low-cost care compared to their peers and benchmark data will earn higher reimbursements.

Frequently asked questions