Handling Criminals: Hospital's Approach And Challenges

Hospitals often face challenging situations when treating patients affiliated with the criminal justice system or when crimes occur on their campuses. The presence of law enforcement in emergency rooms can impact patient care, privacy, and trust, especially in cases where officers refuse to leave during lifesaving resuscitation or when handling sensitive patient information. Hospitals need clear guidelines and investments in non-carceral, trauma-informed approaches to de-escalation and crisis management, including hiring more unarmed security personnel, behavioral response teams, and social workers. Additionally, hospital staff should be trained to identify red flags and mitigate potential violent situations, especially in drug-related cases, where perpetrators or victims may be under the influence and exhibit aggressive behavior.

Hospitals should invest in non-carceral approaches to de-escalation and crisis management

Hospitals are a critical safety net for individuals with psychiatric illnesses, unstable housing, substance use disorders, and many other chronic structural vulnerabilities. They are also the entry point for medical care for patients affiliated with the criminal justice system. As such, hospitals should invest in non-carceral approaches to de-escalation and crisis management.

The ubiquity of law enforcement in emergency rooms is a major health equity issue, impacting patient care, privacy, and trust. There are few institutional policies to regulate their presence or guide medical providers in navigating interactions with officers. This lack of clear guidelines can leave healthcare workers vulnerable and can lead to conflict with law enforcement.

Hospitals should direct investment towards increasing unarmed hospital security personnel, behavioral response teams, social workers, and legal advocates. Robust hospital-based violence intervention programs should be established. For example, in the case of a young man who arrived at the emergency department after being shot, the police officer present refused to move outside the trauma bay, citing that "criminals have no privacy rights." This situation could have been better handled by employing a non-carceral, trauma-informed approach, where the patient's privacy is respected and their immediate medical needs are prioritized.

In the case of suspected criminals requiring medical attention, they are typically transported to the nearest hospital and kept under the custody of the arresting agency or correctional facility. They may be restrained, usually by being handcuffed to the bed, and kept in a private room with an officer posted outside. However, this approach can hinder the patient's recovery and create unnecessary conflict. Hospitals should, therefore, prioritize de-escalation techniques and crisis management strategies that do not rely solely on carceral methods.

Clear guidelines are needed for when police refuse to leave during resuscitation

The presence of law enforcement in emergency rooms is a significant health equity issue that affects patient care, privacy, and trust. Emergency medicine workers often face challenging situations when dealing with police officers who refuse to leave during lifesaving resuscitation of a patient. Hospitals need to invest in non-carceral, trauma-informed approaches to de-escalation and crisis management. This includes hiring more unarmed hospital security personnel, behavioral response teams, social workers, and legal advocates.

Clear guidelines are needed to navigate interactions with police officers, especially when they refuse to leave during resuscitation. In such cases, medical providers should prioritize patient care and firmly but respectfully assert the patient's right to privacy. They should calmly remind the officers that their presence may compromise the patient's health and that they are inviting liability by interfering with medical professionals.

Additionally, contacting the base hospital and involving a nurse or doctor can help de-escalate the situation. Medical personnel should also document the incident, including the officers' disregard for the patient's medical condition, as this creates a record of their actions. It is essential to develop policies and procedures that prevent conflicts and ensure the focus remains on providing better care to the community.

While police presence is necessary in certain situations, such as when a patient is a victim of a crime, clear protocols are needed to balance law enforcement needs with patient privacy and care. These guidelines should outline steps to take when police refuse to leave during resuscitation, ensuring that patient welfare is always the top priority.

Law enforcement presence in emergency rooms impacts patient care, privacy, and trust

The presence of law enforcement in emergency departments (ED) is a prevalent issue in the United States, particularly in county hospitals and trauma centres located in urban areas. Police officers are frequently present in EDs, accompanying individuals in custody, investigating crimes, and responding to calls from hospital staff and patients. This frequent interaction with law enforcement impacts patient care, privacy, and trust.

The relationship between law enforcement and medical professionals in EDs can be delicate, with conflicting priorities and goals. For example, when treating patients injured by gun violence, doctors must make quick clinical decisions, but the presence and investigation of law enforcement can disrupt medical care. In such cases, law enforcement may require medical staff to share protected health information, which can compromise the sanctity of the patient-provider relationship and patient privacy. This disruption to patient privacy and care is further exacerbated by the lack of clear guidelines and policies regarding the role and boundaries of law enforcement in EDs.

The absence of institutional policies and guidelines leaves clinicians with little guidance on how to navigate interactions with law enforcement and can result in contentious relationships between officers and healthcare personnel. This lack of clarity can also impact patient trust in the healthcare system. While some clinicians perceive law enforcement presence as contributing to public safety and clinical care, surveys show that only a minority of emergency physicians and trauma surgeons believe that the presence of police is beneficial to patients. Furthermore, patients' preferences and ability to consent to interactions with law enforcement are often not considered.

To address these issues, hospitals need to implement clear institutional policies and guidelines that prioritize patient care and protect patients' rights. These policies should include protocols for minimizing disruptions to patient care, respecting patient privacy, and upholding accountability for any adverse impacts on patients. Additionally, hospitals should invest in non-carceral, trauma-informed approaches, such as increasing unarmed hospital security personnel, behavioral response teams, and social workers, to reduce the need for law enforcement presence and improve patient outcomes.

Criminals are usually restrained during hospital stays, e.g. handcuffed to beds

In the United States, the emergency department is often the entry point for patients affiliated with the criminal justice system. The presence of law enforcement in these departments is a major health equity issue, impacting patient care, privacy, and trust. Hospitals need clear guidelines on how to handle law enforcement, especially in the case of resuscitation, where the presence of police officers can be a cause for concern and conflict.

Criminals or suspects are usually restrained during hospital stays, often handcuffed to their beds. This is a common occurrence, especially if the injuries were sustained during an arrest. In such cases, the patient is kept in a private room, with an officer outside, and restrained as necessary. If the patient can walk, they may be handcuffed and taken to a jail cell to recover. The number of guards and the specifics of the restraints depend on the situation and the capacity of the hospital.

In some cases, a prison may have a hospital wing, or there may be a prison hospital in larger cities. In Philadelphia, for example, there is a smaller prison within the prison system where prisoners with medical complications are held.

The presence of law enforcement in hospitals, particularly in the case of restraining patients, raises ethical concerns. Hospitals should invest in non-carceral, trauma-informed approaches to de-escalation and crisis management. This includes hiring more unarmed security personnel, behavioral response teams, social workers, and legal advocates.

Victims of certain crimes, like rape, decide if the incident is reported to police

In the case of victims of rape, it is entirely their decision whether or not to report the incident to the police. Hospitals are required to treat victims of sexual assault, regardless of whether they choose to report the incident or not. In the state of Louisiana, for example, victims must be treated as regular emergency room patients if they do not wish to report the incident. Hospitals must also preserve, in strict confidentiality, for a period of 30 days, any tests, procedures, and samples that may serve as potential evidence.

If a victim of sexual assault decides to report the incident to the police, they can expect a detective to reach out to them. They will also be offered a sexual assault medical forensic exam, also known as a "rape kit", to gather evidence. This may include taking pictures of the victim's body to document injuries, collecting DNA evidence, and gathering items of clothing. The victim has the option to decline any portion of the exam that they do not want to participate in. Evidence can also be collected if the victim does not want to file a police report, and it can be stored for a minimum of ten years, or until the victim's 28th birthday if they were a minor at the time of the assault. This gives the victim time to decide whether or not to pursue criminal charges.

It is important to note that the presence of law enforcement in emergency rooms can be a sensitive issue, impacting patient care, privacy, and trust. There is a need for clear guidelines on how emergency medicine workers should handle interactions with law enforcement to ensure the privacy and rights of patients are respected.

Frequently asked questions