Emtala Compliance: Hospitals Face Legal Action For Noncompliance

The Emergency Medical Treatment and Labor Act (EMTALA) ensures that patients receive a medical screening examination and stabilizing treatment for emergency medical conditions, regardless of their insurance status or ability to pay. EMTALA also governs the transfer of patients between hospitals, requiring the transferring hospital to provide ongoing care, medical records, and confirmation of the receiving hospital's capacity and agreement to accept the transfer. Hospitals and physicians that violate EMTALA may face civil monetary penalties, exclusion from Medicare and state healthcare programs, and loss of Medicare certification. Patients, healthcare workers, and others can file EMTALA complaints through the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) web portal, triggering an investigation and potential penalties for noncompliant hospitals.

Hospitals must offer screening and treatment to all, regardless of insurance or ability to pay

The Emergency Medical Treatment and Labor Act (EMTALA) is a US law that ensures anyone who comes to a hospital emergency department receives a medical screening examination and, if necessary, emergency stabilising treatment, regardless of their insurance status or ability to pay.

EMTALA applies to any individual who "comes to the emergency department" with an emergency medical condition. This is defined as a condition with acute symptoms of sufficient severity that the absence of immediate medical attention could result in serious jeopardy to a person's health, including that of an unborn child, or serious impairment to bodily functions or organs.

Under EMTALA, hospitals are required to offer a screening exam, even if the patient does not have insurance. If the patient is found to have an emergency medical condition, the hospital must offer treatment so that the condition does not materially worsen. This treatment must be provided regardless of the patient's insurance status or ability to pay. If the hospital does not have the capacity to stabilise the patient, they must arrange an appropriate transfer to another hospital that can provide the required treatment.

Hospitals that violate EMTALA may face civil monetary penalties, substantial fines, and even the loss of their Medicare certification. The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) has a web portal for patients, healthcare workers, and others to file an EMTALA complaint. The Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) Office of the Inspector General (OIG) may impose civil monetary penalties on hospitals or physicians found to be in violation of EMTALA. These penalties can be significant, ranging from $59,973 to $119,942 per violation, depending on the size of the hospital.

It is important to note that EMTALA does not apply to the transfer of stable patients. However, if a patient is unstable, the transferring hospital must provide ongoing care within its capabilities until the transfer to minimise risks, provide medical records, and confirm that the receiving hospital has the necessary resources and has agreed to accept the transfer.

Hospitals must stabilise patients or transfer them to a hospital that can

The Emergency Medical Treatment and Labor Act (EMTALA) requires that anyone coming to a hospital emergency department requesting evaluation or treatment must receive a medical screening examination. If a patient has an emergency medical condition, the hospital must stabilise them, regardless of their insurance status or ability to pay. If the hospital does not have the capabilities to stabilise the patient, they must transfer them to a hospital that can. This transfer must be "appropriate", meaning the transferring hospital must first provide ongoing care within its capabilities until the transfer to minimise transfer risks. They must also provide copies of medical records, and confirm that the receiving facility has the space, staff, and agreement to treat the patient. Additionally, the transfer must be made with qualified personnel and appropriate medical equipment.

EMTALA applies when an individual "comes to the emergency department" of a hospital. A dedicated emergency department is defined as a specially equipped and staffed area of the hospital used a significant portion of the time for the initial evaluation and treatment of outpatients for emergency medical conditions. This means that hospital-based outpatient clinics not equipped to handle medical emergencies are not obligated under EMTALA and can refer patients to a nearby emergency department.

A patient is considered stable for transfer if the treating physician determines that no material deterioration will occur during the transfer. EMTALA does not apply to the transfer of stable patients. However, if the patient is unstable, the hospital may not transfer them unless a physician certifies that the medical benefits of the transfer outweigh the risks, or the patient makes a transfer request in writing after being informed of the risks.

EMTALA is enforced through the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) and the Office of the Inspector General of the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS). If a violation is reported, it is reviewed by a regional CMS analyst, and further investigation may be conducted by surveyors from the state health department and federal reviewers. HHS-OIG may impose a civil monetary penalty on a hospital or physician for refusing to provide necessary stabilising care or an appropriate transfer. Hospitals may also be concerned about losing their Medicare certification due to EMTALA non-compliance.

Hospitals can be fined for non-compliance, with penalties up to $119,942 per violation

The Emergency Medical Treatment and Labor Act, or EMTALA, is a US law that protects individuals from being refused treatment in hospital emergency departments. EMTALA applies to hospitals that receive Medicare funds, which includes most US hospitals. Under EMTALA, hospitals must offer a screening exam to anyone with an emergency medical condition, regardless of their insurance status. This condition could include severe pain or acute symptoms that could place an individual's health in serious jeopardy if left untreated.

If a hospital fails to comply with EMTALA, individuals can file a complaint with the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS). The Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) Office of the Inspector General (OIG) may then impose a civil monetary penalty on the hospital. These penalties can be up to $119,942 per violation for hospitals with over 100 beds and $59,973 per violation for hospitals with under 100 beds. These fines are a result of refusing to provide necessary stabilizing care or an appropriate transfer for a patient with an emergency medical condition.

EMTALA also governs how patients are transferred between hospitals. Hospitals are required to report to CMS or the state survey agency if they believe they have received an unstable patient from another hospital in violation of EMTALA. Before transferring a patient, the transferring hospital must provide ongoing care within its capabilities, supply medical records, and confirm that the receiving hospital has the capacity and qualified personnel to treat the patient.

In addition to EMTALA, patients are also protected by other federal laws, such as HIPAA, which outlines penalties for non-compliance, including civil and criminal penalties. CMS can issue fines for HIPAA violations related to the HIPAA Administrative Requirements, and the FTC can issue penalties when unsecured PHI data breaches occur.

Physicians can be fined up to $50,000 per violation for refusing to treat emergency cases

The Emergency Medical Treatment and Labor Act (EMTALA) is a US law that prevents hospital emergency departments that receive Medicare funds from refusing to treat patients. Under EMTALA, a qualified professional must check patients for emergency medical conditions, and hospitals must offer to treat these conditions so that they do not materially worsen.

EMTALA also governs how patients are transferred between hospitals. If a patient's condition cannot be stabilised by the staff and facilities available, the hospital must offer to transfer them to another hospital that has the staff and facilities required. The transfer of unstable patients must be "appropriate", meaning the transferring hospital must provide ongoing care within its capacity until the transfer, provide copies of medical records, confirm that the receiving facility can treat the patient and has agreed to accept the transfer, and ensure that the transfer is made with qualified personnel and appropriate medical equipment.

If a hospital believes it has received an unstable patient from another hospital in violation of EMTALA, it must report this to CMS or the state survey agency. Patients who believe their EMTALA rights have been violated can file a complaint with the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS), which has a web portal for this purpose. The Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) Office of the Inspector General (OIG) may impose a civil monetary penalty on a hospital or physician for refusing to provide necessary stabilising care for an individual presenting with an emergency medical condition or an appropriate transfer if the hospital does not have the capacity to stabilise the condition.

For emergency physicians, a civil monetary penalty is a feared consequence of EMTALA enforcement, as a physician can be held individually liable for a fine of up to $50,000, not covered by malpractice insurance. While EMTALA is an actively enforced law, and violation of the EMTALA statute often results in hospital citations and fines, individual physicians are rarely penalized by the OIG following an EMTALA violation. The average settlement amount for an individual physician was $25,625, with total fines against physicians amounting to $205,000.

EMTALA non-compliance is often due to economic issues and ignorance of the rules

The Emergency Medical Treatment and Labor Act (EMTALA) was enacted by the United States Congress in 1986 to prevent hospitals from refusing to treat patients, particularly those who are uninsured or on Medicaid. Despite this, EMTALA non-compliance remains prevalent, often due to economic issues and ignorance of the rules.

Economic Issues

Hospitals face significant financial pressure to reduce costs, and they may view EMTALA obligations as costly and unnecessary. EMTALA rules may require expensive testing that insurance companies or state Medicaid programs refuse to cover. As a result, hospitals may be reluctant to comply with EMTALA, especially when faced with uncompensated or under-compensated care. This can lead to "patient dumping," where uninsured patients are involuntarily transferred to another hospital for financial reasons.

Ignorance of the Rules

While most emergency department (ED) physicians are aware of EMTALA, many specialists are unfamiliar with their obligations under the law, particularly when they are on-call. Some smaller, rural EDs may be staffed with family physicians who are less knowledgeable about EMTALA. Knowledge gaps exist, especially regarding the required obligations for psychiatric patients and legal complexities related to pregnancy emergencies. Physicians may also be unsure of their liability due to the lack of uniformity in court interpretations of the statute, which has limited EMTALA's effectiveness.

To address EMTALA non-compliance, enforcement is carried out by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) and the Office of the Inspector General of the Department of Health and Human Services. Reported violations are reviewed by a regional CMS analyst, and further investigations may be conducted by state health department surveyors and federal reviewers. These investigations review compliance with all EMTALA rules, including medical screening examinations, delivery of stabilizing treatment, and compliance with transfer rules. Hospitals found in violation may face substantial fines and lose their Medicare certification.

Frequently asked questions