Hamas' Tactics: Hospitals And Schools As Shields

The conflict between Israel and Hamas has been ongoing for years, with Israel accusing Hamas of using human shields and hiding among civilians in hospitals and schools. In 2014, Hamas denied these claims, stating that the high population density in Gaza resulted in their operations being near civilian areas. More recently, in 2023, Hamas again denied using hospitals as human shields, and media investigations have refuted accusations of Hamas using Gaza hospitals and schools as military bases. However, Israel has presented video and photo evidence of Hamas placing weapons in and near schools and hospitals, and European Union nations have condemned Hamas for using hospitals and civilians as shields. The conflict has resulted in a stalemate, with hundreds of doctors and patients caught in the crossfire.

Israel claims Hamas uses hospitals and schools for military purposes

Israel has accused Hamas of using hospitals and schools for military purposes, including hiding weapons in and firing rockets from these locations. These accusations have been used to justify attacks on hospitals and schools in Gaza. However, these claims have been refuted or remain unsupported by media and human rights group investigations. For example, Hamas officials have denied using Al-Shifa Hospital as a human shield, and media organizations such as The New York Times and Amnesty International have stated that Israel has not provided credible evidence to support its claims.

During the 2014 Israel-Gaza conflict, there were allegations that Hamas fired rockets from schools. However, Hamas denied these accusations, stating that the crowded landscape of the Gaza Strip left them with little option but to operate near civilian areas. United Nations investigations into these claims found them to be untrue. In interviews with Gazan refugees, reporters from The Independent and The Guardian concluded that it was a "myth" that Hamas forced civilians to stay in areas under attack, with refugees stating that they did not heed IDF warnings because even areas declared safe by Israel had been shelled.

In 2023, Israel released video evidence allegedly showing Hamas' use of a hospital as a command center, but multiple news agencies, including The New York Times and Amnesty International, concluded that the evidence was not conclusive. Israel has also shared photos and videos during its ground operations in Gaza, claiming that they show Hamas placing weapons in and near schools and other U.N. facilities. However, these accusations have not been confirmed by third-party investigators and have been refuted by survivors and witnesses.

The use of human shields and the misuse of prominent civilian targets by Hamas have been widely condemned. In 2023, 27 European Union nations jointly condemned Hamas for using hospitals and civilians as human shields. However, it is important to note that international rights scholars have argued that Israel exploits allegations of Hamas' misuse of civilian infrastructure to cover up atrocities against Palestinian civilians and avoid sanctions for breaches of international law.

Hamas denies using human shields, saying high population density means they operate near civilians

The use of human shields by Hamas has been a contentious issue, with accusations and denials coming from both sides. Hamas, a Palestinian Islamic political organization, has been accused by Israel and its allies of using civilians and civilian infrastructure, such as hospitals and schools, as human shields during military conflicts. Hamas, on the other hand, has consistently denied these allegations, arguing that the high population density in Gaza results in their operations being unavoidably close to civilian areas.

In 2014, Hamas spokesman Sami Abu Zuhri stated that the group's policy was to encourage civilians to confront Israeli warplanes with their bare chests to protect their homes. This statement led to accusations from Israel and the European Union that Hamas was effectively using civilians as human shields. However, Hamas leaders have denied these accusations, claiming that they do not use their people as human shields. They have also pointed to prior United Nations investigations that found no evidence of Hamas firing rockets from schools.

The issue of Hamas' use of hospitals and schools as military bases has been particularly controversial. Israel has claimed that Hamas uses these civilian facilities for military purposes, such as housing command centers and launching attacks. In 2023, Israel's war against Hamas focused on Gaza's Shifa Hospital, with Israel alleging that Hamas had built a vast underground command center beneath it. However, these claims have been disputed by media investigations and human rights groups, who found no credible evidence to support the allegations.

The crowded landscape of the Gaza Strip has also been cited by Hamas as a reason for their operations being near civilian areas. In a 2014 interview, a Hamas official acknowledged that the group fired at Israel from civilian areas but attributed it to "mistakes" and the lack of open zones in the densely populated region. Additionally, reporters from The Independent and The Guardian concluded that it was a "myth" that Hamas forced civilians to stay in areas under attack, as many refugees chose to remain even when warned by the IDF due to a lack of safe options.

The accusations and denials of using human shields by both Hamas and Israel highlight the complexity of the conflict and the challenges of verifying information during military engagements. The high population density in Gaza and the proximity of civilian areas to military operations further complicate the situation. As a result, the issue of human shields remains a highly contested aspect of the Israel-Gaza conflict, with both sides presenting conflicting evidence and interpretations.

Israel justifies attacks on hospitals and schools by citing international law

Israel has justified its attacks on hospitals and schools by citing international law, specifically the Geneva Conventions, which state that a hospital or school used for military purposes loses its protection. Israel has accused Hamas of using hospitals and schools as military bases, command centers, and to store weapons.

Israel claims that Hamas has built a vast underground command center below Gaza's Shifa Hospital, and that Hamas terrorists posed as medical staff during a raid on Al-Shifa Hospital in April 2024. Israel also provided evidence of Hamas using a hospital to detain hostages. However, these accusations have been refuted or remain unsupported by media and third-party investigations. Amnesty International, for example, stated that it had not seen any credible evidence to support Israel's claims regarding Al-Shifa Hospital.

During the 2014 Gaza war, the UN special rapporteur on the occupied Palestinian territories, Francesca Albanese, criticized Israel's labeling of Palestinian casualties as "human shields," arguing that this justified the killing or destruction of anyone in Gaza. Israel has also been criticized by UN experts for undermining the legal framework for the protection of civilians in armed conflicts and for violating international law through indiscriminate attacks on civilians, civilian objects, and educational institutions.

In response to accusations of targeting hospitals, Israel has argued that Hamas embeds its military operations within hospitals, making them valid military targets. Israel has also stated that it is not targeting civilians and is taking steps to reduce civilian casualties, such as providing warnings, facilitating evacuations, and supplying medical teams and supplies.

The debate surrounding Israel's attacks on hospitals and schools is complex and highly contentious, with allegations and justifications made by both sides. While Israel cites international law to justify its actions, there are also concerns raised by UN experts and human rights groups about Israel's compliance with international humanitarian law and its obligations to protect civilians.

Media investigations refute accusations against Hamas

In 2014, Hamas denied using human shields, pointing to prior United Nations investigations that found no evidence to support claims that the group had fired rockets from schools. In interviews with Gazan refugees, reporters from The Independent and The Guardian concluded that it was a "myth" that Hamas forced civilians to stay in areas under attack against their will.

In 2023, Hamas denied using Al-Shifa Hospital as a human shield, stating that the allegations had "no basis in truth". However, Israel has repeatedly accused Hamas of using hospitals and schools as military bases and human shields, including during the 2024 Nuseirat rescue operation and the Al-Tabaeen school attack.

Media investigations and human rights groups have refuted these accusations, finding no evidence to support the claims. For example, following the release of video evidence by Israel in November 2023, multiple news agencies, including the New York Times and Amnesty International, concluded that the evidence did not demonstrate the use of a command center by Hamas.

In addition, accusations of Hamas using hospitals and schools as cover have been characterized as part of a disinformation campaign, with no evidence to support such claims. The high population density in Gaza has resulted in Hamas operating near civilian areas, and the crowded landscape of the Strip limits options for operating away from civilian areas.

While Israel has justified its attacks on hospitals and schools by accusing Hamas of using them for military purposes, these accusations remain disputed and have not been confirmed by third-party investigators.

International rights scholars argue Israel exploits allegations to cover up atrocities

International rights scholars have argued that Israel exploits allegations of Hamas using hospitals and schools as human shields to cover up atrocities against Palestinian civilians and pre-empt sanctions for breaches of international law. For instance, prominent civilian targets, such as the Al-Jalaa media tower, have been destroyed by Israeli forces under accusations that Hamas had misused them militarily. However, these accusations have not been confirmed by third-party investigators and have been refuted by survivors and witnesses.

Israel has claimed that Hamas uses Gaza's main hospital, Al-Shifa, for military purposes and has built a vast underground command center below it. However, Amnesty International has stated that it has not seen any credible evidence to support Israel's claim. Additionally, the New York Times reported that Gazan civilians have been pushing Hamas fighters away from their school shelters to prevent attacks by Israel, indicating that they are not willing to be human shields.

Hamas has denied using human shields, stating that the high population density in Gaza results in their operations being near civilian areas. They have also pointed to previous United Nations investigations that found no evidence of Hamas firing rockets from schools. In contrast, Israeli officials have accused Hamas of hiding behind innocent children to ensure their survival.

The conflict between Israel and Hamas has resulted in allegations of war crimes and genocide by both sides. International law experts and human rights groups have accused Israel of committing war crimes, with the UN Independent International Commission of Inquiry on the Occupied Palestinian Territory stating there was "clear evidence" of such crimes. Similarly, several world leaders and human rights scholars have accused Israel of genocide, citing Israeli statements that indicate an "intent to destroy" the population of Gaza.

In summary, international rights scholars argue that Israel exploits allegations of Hamas using hospitals and schools as human shields to justify its military actions and divert attention from potential atrocities and breaches of international law. While the use of human shields by Hamas is a contentious issue, the focus should also be on Israel's conduct and its potential violations of international law and human rights.

Frequently asked questions